A small pepper plant bearing red and yellow peppers beside an eagle-shaped ornament on a windowsill.

Cover image supplied from the owner-authorized Psychology Notebook reserve.

The Ordinary Magic of Getting Through

We have a strange habit of treating resilience as a heroic achievement.

Someone survives a difficult childhood, grows up in poverty, experiences loss, or lives through a disaster, and somehow manages to build a reasonably good life.

We call them extraordinary.

We admire their strength, their determination, their remarkable ability to overcome the odds.

And then we invent another motivational poster about never giving up.

But psychologist Ann Masten discovered something rather inconvenient for the entire resilience-as-superpower industry.

Resilience is often surprisingly ordinary.

The Magic That Isn't Particularly Magical

In 2001, Masten published a landmark paper called Ordinary Magic: Resilience Processes in Development.

After studying children exposed to poverty, violence, family instability, homelessness, and other adversities, she reached an important conclusion.

Many children who managed to develop well despite serious difficulties weren't necessarily exceptional individuals with extraordinary psychological powers.

Their resilience often depended on ordinary adaptive systems.

A caring adult.

A reasonably supportive school.

The ability to solve problems.

Opportunities to develop competence.

A sense that their actions could make a difference.

Nothing particularly glamorous.

No secret mental technique. No superhuman tolerance for suffering.

Just the ordinary machinery of human development doing what it evolved to do.

In 2024, Masten received the Grawemeyer Award in Psychology for her contributions to this understanding of resilience.

Resilience Isn't Something You Either Have or Don't

We often speak about resilience as though it were a personality trait.

Some people are strong.

Others are fragile.

End of story.

Masten's research suggests a much more interesting picture.

Resilience is a dynamic capacity that emerges through interactions among individuals, relationships, families, institutions, and communities.

It isn't located exclusively inside a person's head.

A child may struggle in one environment and flourish in another.

The same individual may adapt successfully to one challenge and need substantial help with another.

And someone who seems to be doing badly now may develop remarkably well later, when circumstances and support change.

This is important because it shifts the question.

Instead of asking What's wrong with this person?

We can also ask:

Which adaptive systems are working, which are under pressure, and which need support?

The Surprisingly Short List

Across different studies, Masten identified a recurring group of protective factors.

Reliable relationships with caring adults.

Cognitive abilities and self-regulation skills.

A sense of competence and personal effectiveness.

Supportive friendships.

Effective schools and community institutions.

Hope, meaning, and cultural traditions that provide connection and guidance.

Of course, none of these guarantees a good outcome.

But together they illustrate an important principle.

Resilience is not simply the ability to endure difficulty. It is also having access to systems that make adaptation possible.

And those systems operate at several levels.

A person needs resources.

A family needs stability.

A school needs to function.

A community needs institutions capable of helping people when things go wrong.

You cannot replace all of that with a breathing exercise and a positive attitude.

When the Protective Systems Break

Perhaps the most important part of Masten's work concerns what happens when adversity damages the very systems that normally help us cope.

Poverty doesn't merely create financial inconvenience.

It can undermine housing stability, education, health, and family resources.

War doesn't simply expose children to frightening events.

It can destroy schools, separate families, disrupt communities, and remove the people who would normally provide safety.

Abuse can be particularly damaging when the person who should provide protection becomes a source of danger.

In these circumstances, the problem isn't that someone has insufficient resilience.

The systems that would ordinarily support resilience may themselves be compromised.

And the solution cannot consist entirely of teaching individuals to tolerate more suffering.

Sometimes we need to restore relationships, rebuild institutions, reduce danger, and provide the resources that make recovery possible.

The Ordinary Work of Becoming Resilient

There's something reassuring about this perspective.

Resilience doesn't have to mean being fearless.

It doesn't require remaining calm through every crisis.

It doesn't mean never becoming depressed, overwhelmed, frightened, or exhausted.

Nor does it mean that everybody will recover from every adversity.

But it does suggest that the capacity to adapt can be supported and developed.

Through relationships.

Through learning.

Through opportunities to experience competence.

Through more predictable environments and access to help.

And sometimes through something as ordinary as having one dependable person who remains present when life becomes difficult.

Perhaps We Have Been Asking the Wrong Question

We spend an enormous amount of time asking people to become stronger.

More disciplined.

More stress-resistant.

More capable of tolerating uncertainty and adversity.

And perhaps some of that effort is useful.

But Masten's research suggests another question worth asking.

Instead of demanding extraordinary resilience from individuals, what if we made the ordinary conditions that support resilience more widely available?

Better relationships.

Safer environments.

Functioning schools.

Opportunities to learn, recover, and regain a sense of agency.

None of this sounds particularly heroic.

It probably wouldn't sell many motivational posters.

But it might do something rather more important.

Help people build lives that don't require them to be heroes just to get through the day.

Framework and scope

Ordinary protective processes do not guarantee recovery from severe adversity; greater adversity can reduce the likelihood of positive adaptation. Early caregiving is important but not the sole influence. Religious belief is one possible meaning-making resource, not a requirement. Resilience is never an obligation to tolerate abuse, poverty or unsafe conditions, nor a basis for blaming people for circumstances outside their control.

References

Keep reading

Explore the writing archive →

Stay in touch

More essays and updates on ABVX Substack.

Read and subscribe on Substack →