
Cover photograph by Anton Biletskyi-Volokh.
Two people hear exactly the same criticism.
One gets upset, thinks about it, and eventually decides whether there's something useful to learn.
The other feels attacked, immediately blames the person who said it, withdraws from the conversation, and spends the next three days mentally preparing a defence against an accusation nobody actually made.
Same situation.
Very different psychological machinery.
And the difference may have less to do with the intensity of their emotions than with how they manage them.
The Defenses That Keep Us Together
Psychological defenses exist for a reason.
They help us deal with experiences that threaten our sense of stability: shame, rejection, helplessness, internal conflict, or feelings we aren't quite ready to face.
Most operate largely outside conscious awareness.
We don't usually decide to project, repress, or rationalise.
By the time we start explaining our reactions, the defense may already be doing its job.
Psychiatrist George E. Vaillant studied how different defensive styles relate to psychological adjustment over time.
His work helped establish a hierarchy, ranging from defenses involving severe distortions of reality to more adaptive ways of managing emotional distress.
The broad categories are useful, although contemporary clinical instruments use a more detailed classification.
Pathological or psychotic-level defenses involve profound distortions of reality, such as psychotic denial or delusional projection.
Immature defenses may provide immediate relief at a considerable interpersonal cost. Projection, acting out, passive aggression, and retreat into fantasy are examples.
Neurotic defenses preserve more contact with reality but can distance us from difficult emotions. Repression, displacement, intellectualisation, reaction formation, and isolation of affect belong to this territory.
Mature defenses allow distress to be managed with greater flexibility and less distortion. Humour, sublimation, anticipation, altruism, and suppression are familiar examples.
Suppression here means consciously putting a difficult feeling aside until a more appropriate moment, rather than pretending it doesn't exist.
The distinction isn't that mature people never experience unpleasant emotions.
They simply have more adaptive ways of responding to them.
When Protection Damages Connection
Now consider what happens when these defenses enter a relationship.
Your partner tells you they're hurt by something you said.
You might recognise their feelings, experience some discomfort, and try to understand what happened.
Or you might immediately decide they're too sensitive.
You might counterattack.
You might explain, with impeccable logic, why their feelings make absolutely no sense.
Or withdraw until the entire situation becomes so uncomfortable that nobody wants to discuss it again.
All these reactions may reduce immediate emotional tension.
But they don't necessarily help the relationship.
This is where defensive functioning becomes closely connected to relational maladjustment: difficulty maintaining workable, flexible relationships with other people.
The person may repeatedly misinterpret intentions, struggle with disagreement, withdraw from intimacy, or respond to relatively manageable conflicts as though their entire sense of self were under attack.
Importantly, strong emotions alone don't make a reaction pathological.
What matters is the broader pattern: how persistent it is, whether it fits the situation, and how much it interferes with relationships and everyday functioning.
The Problem with Having Only One Answer
Imagine someone whose automatic response to criticism is withdrawal.
It may have been a perfectly sensible strategy in childhood, particularly if disagreement brought punishment or humiliation.
But now they're an adult.
Their partner asks for a conversation. Their manager offers constructive feedback. A friend expresses disappointment.
And every time, the same response appears.
Withdraw. Disconnect. Wait for the danger to pass.
It doesn't matter that the circumstances have changed.
The strategy hasn't.
Another person might have the opposite pattern.
Every disagreement becomes a confrontation.
Someone else tries to manage uncertainty through control.
Another says yes to everything and expresses resentment indirectly.
Different defenses. The same underlying difficulty.
One protective response has become the answer to too many different questions.
Psychological flexibility means being able to respond differently when circumstances require it.
Sometimes withdrawing is wise.
Sometimes confrontation is necessary.
Sometimes humour helps.
Sometimes you need to tolerate an uncomfortable feeling long enough to have an honest conversation.
No single strategy works everywhere.
What Personality Disorders Can Teach Us About Flexibility
Difficulties with emotional regulation and relationships can be particularly pronounced in some personality disorders.
Borderline personality disorder, for example, may involve intense emotional responses, fear of abandonment, unstable relationships, and difficulties maintaining a consistent sense of self.
Under stress, familiar protective patterns can become especially difficult to interrupt.
But BPD is not simply a disorder of having too few coping strategies. Nor does every person with BPD respond in the same way.
The clinical picture is more complex, and effective treatment involves more than learning to calm down.
Evidence-based psychotherapies, including dialectical behaviour therapy and mentalisation-based treatment, can help people develop skills for managing emotions, understanding mental states, navigating relationships, and responding to distress.
Psychodynamic therapies may also help people recognise and gradually transform habitual defensive patterns.
The goal isn't to eliminate every automatic reaction.
It's to create more possibilities between feeling threatened and acting on that feeling.
Progress Isn't Always Feeling Better
One of the more interesting things about psychological change is that improvement doesn't necessarily begin with feeling less.
Sometimes you still experience the same anger.
The same anxiety.
The same urge to withdraw, control, attack, or apologise for something that wasn't your responsibility.
But something changes.
You notice the reaction earlier.
You recognise the familiar pattern.
You realise that the situation might not require the response you've used for the past twenty years.
And perhaps, for the first time, you try something different.
Instead of attacking, you ask a question.
Instead of disappearing, you explain that you need some time.
Instead of agreeing resentfully, you say no.
Instead of treating criticism as proof of your worthlessness, you consider whether it contains any useful information.
The emotion may still be there.
But it no longer has the only vote.
A Larger Repertoire for Living
Psychological defenses are not enemies to defeat.
They're part of the mind's ordinary equipment for dealing with stress.
And even less adaptive defenses can serve an immediate protective function when someone is overwhelmed.
The difficulty arises when they become rigid, automatic, and disconnected from what the situation actually requires.
A more mature defensive style generally allows us to remain in better contact with reality, our own emotional experience, and the people around us.
Not perfectly. Not all the time.
But often enough to make a difference.
Psychological maturity isn't having the perfect response to every situation. It's having more than one response available.
And perhaps the most meaningful sign of progress isn't that life has stopped triggering our old defenses.
It's that an old defense no longer gets to decide what happens next.
Framework and scope
Vaillant's broad defensive hierarchy is distinct from the seven-level Defense Mechanisms Rating Scales (DMRS). Defenses from different levels can coexist within the same person; the hierarchy is not a fixed ladder of personal development. Defense mechanisms and voluntary coping strategies are related but not identical. Relational maladjustment here is descriptive, not an independent DSM or ICD diagnosis. External circumstances and the safety of relationships also influence psychological functioning.
References
- George E. Vaillant (2011), Involuntary Coping Mechanisms: A Psychodynamic Perspective
- George E. Vaillant (1976), The Relation of Choice of Ego Mechanisms of Defense to Adult Adjustment
- Bond (2004), Empirical Studies of Defense Style: Relationships with Psychopathology and Change
- Crotty et al. (2024), Psychotherapies for the Treatment of Borderline Personality Disorder: A Systematic Review
