Framed photographs showing abstract shapes and everyday details on a warmly lit gallery wall.

Cover photograph by Anton Biletskyi-Volokh.

An unanswered message.

A difficult conversation.

An unexpected problem at work.

Under ordinary circumstances, you might consider several explanations, weigh your options, and decide what to do.

Under stress, the same situation can suddenly become remarkably simple.

They don't care about me.

Everything is going wrong.

I have to do something. Right now.

The world hasn't necessarily become more dangerous.

But your ability to imagine alternatives has become considerably smaller.

And this may be one of the most interesting things about psychological regulation.

Stress doesn't just change how we feel. It can change how much psychological space we have to think.

The Dimensions of the Mind

Psychoanalyst Donald Meltzer developed a fascinating concept known as the dimensionality of mental functioning.

In his 1975 work Explorations in Autism, he described different ways of experiencing psychological space, relationships, and time.

This wasn't a literal theory of four anatomical dimensions inside the brain. It was a psychoanalytic model of how the mind organises experience.

Still, it offers a useful metaphor.

One-dimensional functioning is the most restricted. Experience is organised around immediate movement towards or away from something. There is little room for reflecting on inner states or relationships.

At the extreme, experience becomes little more than an urgent response.

Something is happening. React.

Two-dimensional functioning resembles a world of surfaces.

People and experiences are perceived without much psychological depth.

Good or bad. Safe or dangerous. Accepting or rejecting.

There is little space for the possibility that someone can love you and still be angry, or that a painful situation might have several explanations.

Everything feels immediate.

Three-dimensional functioning introduces an inside.

You have an inner world. Other people have inner worlds too.

Feelings can be held, examined, and understood rather than immediately discharged through action.

Someone's behaviour may have motives you cannot see.

And your own emotional reaction doesn't have to become the entire truth about what happened.

Four-dimensional functioning adds a fuller relationship with time.

The present becomes part of a history and a possible future.

You can remember that a difficult conversation doesn't erase ten years of friendship.

That disappointment today doesn't determine the rest of your life.

That a feeling can be intense without being permanent.

Meltzer's dimensions are theoretical descriptions, not validated neurological stages or measurements of psychological maturity.

But they suggest something worth considering.

Sometimes emotional distress seems to flatten our experience.

We lose perspective, complexity, and the ability to imagine what happens next.

And regaining psychological space may matter as much as reducing emotional intensity.

Before We Can Regulate Ourselves, Someone Helps Us

A newborn doesn't arrive equipped with an adult capacity for emotional regulation.

The systems involved in detecting emotionally significant events develop on a different timetable from the prefrontal networks involved in complex regulation, planning, and cognitive control.

This developmental relationship has been studied extensively by neuroscientist Nim Tottenham.

Her research examines how early caregiving experiences influence the development of connections between the amygdala and prefrontal regions.

But emotional development isn't simply a story about an overactive amygdala waiting for the prefrontal cortex to take charge.

The brain develops through interactions among many systems, and caregiving plays an important part in shaping those interactions.

A distressed child may become calmer through a familiar voice, a predictable response, physical comfort, or the presence of someone who helps make an overwhelming experience manageable.

This is co-regulation.

Over time, these interactions can help support the development of self-regulation.

But consider two difficult environments.

In one, the child receives too little reliable support.

The adult is frightening, unavailable, or unpredictable.

In another, the adult intervenes so consistently and anxiously that the child has limited opportunities to practise handling manageable frustration independently.

These environments are not equivalent, and neither produces an inevitable psychological outcome.

But both raise an important developmental question.

How does a person learn to manage distress if distress was either overwhelming or never allowed to become manageable through practice?

For some adults, the answer remains complicated.

They may seek urgent reassurance when anxious, become overwhelmed when alone with difficult feelings, or struggle to tolerate uncertainty without someone else providing an immediate solution.

Not necessarily because they're incapable of self-regulation.

But because the skills and expectations involved in regulating emotion develop through experience, and those experiences differ considerably.

Three Systems, Three Different Questions

Another way to understand our responses comes from psychologist Jeffrey Alan Gray's Reinforcement Sensitivity Theory, later revised with Neil McNaughton.

The revised model describes three broad systems involved in motivation, threat, and conflict.

The Behavioral Approach System (BAS) responds to incentives and opportunities.

Is there something worth pursuing?

When approach motivation is strong, we may feel energetic, curious, and ready to act. But reward sensitivity can also contribute to impulsive choices in certain circumstances.

The Fight–Flight–Freeze System (FFFS) is concerned with aversive threats and defensive responses.

Is there something I need to escape or defend myself against?

Greater sensitivity to threat may encourage caution, avoidance, or protective action.

The Behavioral Inhibition System (BIS) is particularly interesting because it responds to conflicts between competing motivations.

I want this. But what if it goes wrong?

Imagine being offered an exciting new job.

BAS notices the opportunities.

FFFS responds to potential threats.

BIS becomes involved when approach and avoidance motivations conflict, increasing vigilance, risk assessment, and hesitation.

This is a simplified account of a theoretical model, not a description of three independent switches in the brain.

But it helps explain why the same opportunity can produce enthusiasm in one person and paralysis in another.

And why some decisions become harder precisely because we want them so much.

When the Body Refuses to Cooperate

Now imagine standing in front of an audience.

You've prepared your presentation. You know your subject. Nothing in the room is physically threatening.

Then your voice disappears.

Your legs feel weak. Your thoughts become inaccessible. You stare at the audience and suddenly cannot remember why you're there.

People often describe experiences like this as freezing or shutting down.

They can involve interactions among attention, autonomic arousal, learned threat responses, and other physiological processes.

Popular explanations sometimes attribute these states to a specific dorsal vagal shutdown mechanism.

That claim comes from polyvagal theory, whose detailed neurophysiological explanations remain scientifically disputed.

The experience of freezing or feeling disconnected is real.

But we should be careful about assuming that a single nerve pathway explains it.

What matters psychologically is that the body can interfere with capacities that remain perfectly available in less threatening situations.

You know what to say.

You simply cannot access it at that moment.

The Window of Tolerance

Psychiatrist Daniel Siegel popularised the concept of the window of tolerance, a useful clinical metaphor for the range of emotional arousal within which a person can remain reasonably engaged and functional.

When arousal becomes overwhelming, we may become agitated, panicked, or excessively vigilant.

At the other extreme, we may feel numb, disconnected, or unable to mobilise ourselves.

Between these extremes lies a range in which difficult emotions can be experienced without completely disrupting our ability to think, connect, and act.

The window isn't a literal neurological measurement with fixed boundaries.

And it changes with sleep, health, circumstances, perceived safety, and available support.

But the idea captures something important.

Psychological resilience doesn't require remaining calm all the time.

It involves being able to experience discomfort without immediately losing access to every other capacity.

You can feel anxious and still think.

You can feel angry and still listen.

You can be uncertain and still make a reasonable decision.

What If Stress Isn't Always the Enemy?

Psychologist Alia Crum has explored another interesting variable: our beliefs about stress itself.

Her stress mindset research distinguishes between two broad orientations.

A stress-is-debilitating mindset views stress primarily as something that harms health, performance, and personal development.

A stress-is-enhancing mindset allows for the possibility that some stress responses can support effort, learning, and performance.

Experiments suggest that changing people's interpretations of stress can influence some psychological, behavioural, and physiological responses.

This doesn't mean stress is always beneficial.

Chronic overload, danger, deprivation, and traumatic experiences can cause serious harm. Positive thinking cannot transform unsafe conditions into safe ones.

And a change in mindset cannot replace rest, support, medical care, or improving an objectively harmful environment.

But sometimes the interpretation adds another layer of difficulty.

I'm anxious. That means I can't handle this.

Becomes:

I'm anxious because this matters to me. What would help me respond?

The emotion hasn't disappeared.

But the conclusion drawn from it has changed.

Making Room for Uncertainty

Perhaps all these perspectives meet at one particularly important human capacity.

The ability to remain in uncertainty without immediately treating it as danger.

To experience a feeling without assuming it describes the whole situation.

To recognise a threat response without automatically obeying it.

To want something while acknowledging the risks.

To accept that another person has an internal world we cannot fully know.

And to understand that the present moment, however uncomfortable, is not the entirety of our future.

There will always be things we cannot predict.

Relationships will remain complicated. Plans will fail. People will disappoint us. Opportunities will arrive without guarantees.

Absolute certainty is largely an illusion.

The task isn't to create a life in which nothing unexpected can happen.

It's to develop enough internal space that uncertainty doesn't automatically become an emergency.

Because emotional maturity may have less to do with controlling every feeling than with preserving our capacity to choose while feeling it.

And sometimes the most important change isn't that the world becomes safer, simpler, or more predictable.

It's that our mind becomes spacious enough to hold a world that isn't.

References

Keep reading

Explore the writing archive →

Stay in touch

More essays and updates on ABVX Substack.

Read and subscribe on Substack →