Bowls, fruit, a knife and other items on a kitchen worktop, in monochrome with turquoise edge highlights.

Cover image supplied from the owner-authorized Psychology Notebook reserve.

Why Some People Are More Sensitive to Their Environment

Put two children in exactly the same unfamiliar situation.

One explores the room, talks to strangers, and begins investigating everything that isn't securely attached to the furniture.

The other remains close to a parent, watches carefully, and needs considerably more time before deciding that the world is safe enough to explore.

Same room. Same people. Same situation.

Very different responses.

We tend to explain this through personality.

One child is brave. The other is shy.

But developmental neuroscience suggests something more interesting.

Our responses to stress emerge from an ongoing interaction between biology and experience.

And neither tells the whole story on its own.

The Stress System We Are Born With

The hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis, or HPA axis, helps coordinate the body's hormonal response to demanding situations.

Its activity is influenced by genetics, development, previous experiences, and current circumstances.

One of its main hormonal outputs is cortisol.

But the amount of cortisol someone produces doesn't provide a simple measurement of how frightened or resilient they are.

Cortisol follows a daily rhythm. Its response depends on the type of challenge, the person's age, and many other factors.

Even different aspects of HPA activity, such as baseline cortisol levels and cortisol responses to acute stress, can follow different patterns.

What matters isn't simply whether someone produces more or less cortisol.

It's how the system responds to different demands and how its regulation develops over time.

When Temperament Meets the Environment

Some children are naturally more cautious around unfamiliar situations.

Psychologists describe one relevant temperament pattern as behavioral inhibition.

These children may hesitate before approaching unfamiliar people, objects, or activities.

Research has found associations between fearful temperament and cortisol reactivity, but the relationship isn't universal.

The type of challenge matters.

So does the quality of caregiving.

In a study involving 274 preschool children, researchers found that supportive parenting moderated cortisol responses among children showing particularly strong social inhibition.

In other words, the same temperamental sensitivity can have different physiological consequences depending on the environment.

A cautious child isn't necessarily a future anxious adult.

And sensitivity isn't automatically a defect.

Sometimes it means noticing changes and possible threats sooner.

The important question is what happens when that sensitivity meets a particular environment.

When Experience Gets Under the Skin

Now imagine growing up in an environment where danger is frequent, support is unreliable, and nobody can tell you when the next problem will arrive.

The stress system has to operate under conditions very different from those found in a safe, predictable home.

Researchers sometimes call the lasting influence of social experience on biological functioning biological embedding.

Poverty, violence, neglect, family instability, and other adversities can become associated with changes in stress regulation.

But these changes aren't all in the same direction.

Some studies find heightened cortisol responses.

Others find reduced responses.

And some find little difference on particular measures.

The type of adversity, developmental timing, duration, and available support all matter.

Which brings us to a rather surprising possibility.

When Less Cortisol Doesn't Mean Less Stress

We might expect that children exposed to chronic threat would always produce more cortisol.

After all, more danger should mean more stress.

Unfortunately, biology doesn't follow such convenient rules.

Research has repeatedly found that some children and adults with histories of significant adversity show a blunted cortisol response to acute stress.

The hormonal increase is smaller than expected.

At first glance, this might look like an unusually calm nervous system.

But a reduced cortisol response doesn't necessarily mean someone feels safe, relaxed, or unaffected.

It may reflect altered regulation following prolonged adversity, although the mechanisms and consequences vary.

Nor is it evidence that the adrenal glands have become exhausted.

The system is considerably more complex than a battery that eventually runs out.

And a single cortisol measurement cannot establish that someone's stress response has been damaged by childhood experiences.

Sometimes a system that responds less strongly is not necessarily a system that is coping better.

The Genetics of Sensitivity

There is another interesting complication.

People differ in how strongly their biology responds to environmental influences.

Researchers have investigated genes involved in the regulation of stress hormones, particularly FKBP5 and CRHR1.

FKBP5 participates in the regulation of glucocorticoid receptor signalling, helping influence how cells respond to cortisol.

CRHR1 encodes a receptor involved in the hormonal stress-response cascade.

Some studies have found interactions between genetic variants and childhood maltreatment in relation to later stress regulation or depression.

Research has also identified epigenetic changes associated with particular combinations of genetic variation and early adversity.

But this doesn't mean we have discovered genes that determine who will become anxious, depressed, or traumatised.

The findings are complex, their reproducibility varies, and genetic effects often depend on the population and conditions being studied.

There is no simple DNA test that can tell parents how resilient their child will become.

The Orchid and the Dandelion

Perhaps the most intriguing idea comes from the theory of differential susceptibility.

Traditionally, psychological vulnerability has been understood as something that makes people more likely to suffer in difficult environments.

But what if some people are simply more responsive to their surroundings?

In an unsafe or unsupportive environment, they may experience greater difficulties.

In a particularly supportive environment, they may also benefit more.

Researchers have sometimes illustrated this using two flowers.

Dandelions can grow in a wide range of conditions.

Orchids require more particular environments but can flourish remarkably well when those conditions are right.

It's an appealing metaphor, although human sensitivity doesn't divide neatly into two biological categories.

The more important point is that greater sensitivity to adversity may sometimes coexist with greater responsiveness to positive experiences.

A sensitive nervous system isn't necessarily a weak nervous system.

Its functioning depends partly on what it's responding to.

Biology Is Not a Life Sentence

Early experience matters.

Genetic variation matters.

Temperament matters.

But none of these determines a person's future with absolute certainty.

Stress regulation continues to develop, and later relationships, environmental changes, and appropriate interventions can influence psychological functioning.

This doesn't mean every early biological effect can simply be erased.

Nor does it mean that sufficient optimism will overcome prolonged danger or deprivation.

But it changes the way we understand individual differences.

Instead of dividing people into strong and weak, we can ask more useful questions.

What kinds of situations activate this person's stress response?

What makes regulation easier or more difficult?

Which resources are available?

What role do relationships and environmental conditions play?

And what might help the system respond more flexibly?

Because perhaps the most important thing about stress sensitivity isn't how strongly someone reacts.

It's what happens next.

A nervous system doesn't develop in isolation. It develops in a world.

And understanding that world may be just as important as understanding the biology.

Framework and scope

Baseline cortisol, daily rhythms, acute reactivity and recovery are different measures. The 2025 meta-analysis reports mostly small average associations that vary by measure and adversity; they do not determine an individual child’s outcome. Blunted reactivity is neither adrenal exhaustion nor proof of trauma. Differential susceptibility is not identical to vulnerability and cannot be established by one cortisol test. Orchid and dandelion are metaphors, not fixed biological types; developmental influence does not imply irreversible destiny.

References

Keep reading

Explore the writing archive →

Stay in touch

More essays and updates on ABVX Substack.

Read and subscribe on Substack →