A French sign prohibiting dogs, mounted beside yellow flowers with a wavy visual distortion.

Cover image supplied from the owner-authorized Psychology Notebook reserve.

We like to imagine that our biggest problem is not getting what we want.

Not enough love. Not enough freedom. Not enough success. Not enough opportunities.

But psychoanalysis suggests a rather inconvenient possibility.

Sometimes we are considerably more comfortable wanting something than actually having it.

Because desire is not always pleasant. It can threaten our sense of control, expose us to rejection, or force us to confront things about ourselves we'd rather leave undisturbed.

In Freudian and Lacanian psychoanalysis, hysteria, obsessional neurosis, and phobia offer three different ways of understanding this conflict.

Not three boxes into which every human being must fit.

But three fascinating ways of dealing with the discomfort of desire.

1. The Hysterical Position: Keep Me Wanting

Do you want me? And will you still want me once I'm yours?

In Lacanian theory, hysterical desire is closely connected to the desire of the Other.

Being wanted can become central to a person's sense of identity.

But there's a complication.

Once the desired relationship becomes available, the excitement may disappear. The person who seemed extraordinary from a distance becomes disappointingly ordinary up close.

So desire moves elsewhere.

Towards someone unavailable. A relationship full of uncertainty. A person who might eventually choose them, provided that moment never quite arrives.

The unattainable object has one tremendous advantage.

Reality never gets the chance to disappoint.

Of course, this is a theoretical pattern, not an explanation for everyone who falls in love with unavailable people.

The strengths associated with this style can be considerable: sensitivity to relationships, emotional expressiveness, creativity, and an ability to engage others.

The difficulty begins when recognition becomes essential to self-worth, while actual intimacy feels strangely unsatisfying.

The person may become very good at inspiring desire, but less comfortable with the ordinary reality of being loved.

And perhaps the psychological task isn't to become more desirable.

It's to discover what they want when nobody else is watching.

2. The Obsessional Position: Keep Everything Under Control

I want it. But what if wanting it means losing control?

The obsessional position approaches desire from another direction.

Instead of sustaining longing through dissatisfaction, it may attempt to make desire impossible, postpone it, or place it under increasingly elaborate conditions.

There must be a plan.

The timing must be right.

Every possible consequence must be considered.

Ideally, the decision should carry no uncertainty whatsoever.

Which is an excellent way to avoid making it.

Someone may spend years preparing for a project they genuinely want to begin.

Or endlessly analyse whether a relationship is right for them.

Or turn every spontaneous impulse into a committee meeting involving one person and approximately forty objections.

The capacity for discipline, responsibility, strategic thinking, and delayed gratification can be genuinely valuable.

But these qualities become restrictive when control stops serving life and starts replacing it.

The problem isn't necessarily that the person lacks desire.

It may be that desire feels dangerous precisely because it cannot be completely managed.

If I never quite begin, I never have to discover what happens when I truly want something.

The task, then, isn't to abandon responsibility.

It's to tolerate the fact that meaningful choices rarely come with guarantees.

3. The Phobic Position: Give Anxiety an Address

I know something is frightening. At least now I know what to avoid.

Anxiety can be particularly difficult when it has no clear object.

Something feels wrong. Something dangerous might happen. But the threat remains vague.

In Freud's psychoanalytic account, phobic symptoms can give anxiety a more definite object.

A particular animal. A place. A situation. Something identifiable and, crucially, avoidable.

Now the fear has a location.

If I stay away from that thing, perhaps I can feel safe.

This is one reason the psychoanalytic understanding of phobia is interesting. It asks not only what the person fears, but what psychological function the fear may serve.

Modern research also explains phobias through learning, threat processing, avoidance, and other mechanisms. A phobia does not necessarily conceal a forbidden desire.

And effective treatments, particularly exposure-based cognitive behavioural therapy, do not require discovering a hidden symbolic meaning.

Still, the broader psychological observation is useful.

Avoidance can offer immediate relief.

But every avoided situation may make the world a little smaller.

The ability to anticipate danger can be valuable. Caution, preparation, and sensitivity to risk can protect us.

The difficulty begins when avoiding discomfort becomes more important than pursuing a life we actually want.

A person may become extremely skilled at staying safe while gradually losing the freedom to go anywhere.

When the Symptom Speaks Instead

Freud proposed that neurotic symptoms could express unconscious conflict through compromise formations.

Something unacceptable to consciousness might find an indirect expression through anxiety, inhibition, or repetitive behaviour.

From this perspective, a symptom isn't simply an inconvenience.

It may also represent an attempt to manage something the person cannot easily acknowledge or resolve.

But this is a psychoanalytic interpretation, not a universal explanation of psychological symptoms.

Not every panic attack conceals a desire.

Not every obsession has a symbolic message.

And not every relationship difficulty is a reenactment of childhood.

Sometimes symptoms arise through mechanisms that are better understood through other psychological or medical frameworks.

The useful question is not whether every difficulty hides some mysterious forbidden wish.

It's whether our habitual ways of protecting ourselves are also preventing us from living.

The Freedom to Want Something

These three positions illustrate different relationships with desire.

In the hysterical position, desire may be preserved through dissatisfaction.

In the obsessional position, desire may be postponed through control.

In the phobic position, anxiety may become organised around something that can be avoided.

Different strategies.

A similar possibility: the person remains protected from some of the uncertainty involved in wanting, choosing, and acting.

And perhaps that's where psychological change becomes interesting.

Not when we finally obtain everything we want.

But when we can tolerate wanting something without needing to turn it into a drama, an endless calculation, or a reason to escape.

The freedom to desire also means accepting that desire offers no guarantee of safety, satisfaction, or success.

You may be rejected.

You may make a mistake.

You may discover that what you wanted wasn't quite what you imagined.

But at least you will have given yourself the opportunity to find out.

Which is considerably more than an elaborate defence against living can offer.

Framework and scope

Hysterical and obsessional positions are psychoanalytic concepts, not contemporary DSM or ICD diagnoses. The word 'hysterical' is not a gender-specific characteristic or a derogatory label. Obsessional neurosis is not synonymous with obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD). Lacan did not consistently treat phobia as an independent third neurotic structure. Proposed childhood origins and associated strengths are theoretical interpretations, not established causal or personality profiles.

References

Keep reading

Explore the writing archive →

Stay in touch

More essays and updates on ABVX Substack.

Read and subscribe on Substack →