A portrait with glasses, tattoos and blue-green light.

Cover image supplied from the owner-authorized Psychology Notebook reserve.

Lewis Carroll, the psychology of identity, and the Zen-like difficulty of answering a question that assumes we never change.

There is a surprisingly difficult question that we ask people all the time.

Who are you?

Under ordinary circumstances, the answer is straightforward.

You provide your name. Perhaps your profession. Where you come from. Something about your family, interests, or what you are currently doing with your life.

The other person nods.

Identity established.

A remarkably efficient procedure.

Unfortunately, it depends on several assumptions.

That the person answering is sufficiently familiar with themselves.

That their previous understanding of who they are remains useful.

And that language can provide an answer stable enough to satisfy the question.

Lewis Carroll's Alice discovers what happens when all three assumptions stop working.

In Chapter V of Alice's Adventures in Wonderland, she encounters a Caterpillar sitting on a mushroom, smoking a hookah and apparently enjoying a life free from unnecessary explanations.

The Caterpillar asks who she is.

Alice cannot provide a satisfactory answer.

This is particularly embarrassing because she has always assumed that she knows.

But Wonderland has been playing a rather unpleasant game with her sense of continuity.

Her body keeps changing size.

Familiar words no longer come out correctly.

Ordinary rules of conversation have become unreliable.

And now an exceptionally unhelpful insect expects her to explain herself.

The scene is funny.

But beneath the comedy lies a serious psychological question.

When we answer "Who am I?", are we describing a living, changing experience, or trying to secure it inside a definition that will no longer require revision?

The Question That Sounds Easier Than It Is

The Caterpillar begins with a simple demand.

Who are you?

It is not a particularly welcoming opening.

Alice tries to answer politely, but she immediately encounters a difficulty.

She knew who she was when she woke up.

Since then, however, she seems to have changed several times.

This is an interesting answer because it does not suggest complete ignorance.

Alice remembers having an identity.

She remembers a familiar version of herself.

What she cannot establish is whether that identity still describes her accurately.

The problem concerns continuity.

Something that was true this morning no longer feels entirely reliable this afternoon.

We usually treat identity as a kind of stable possession.

I have a name.

A history.

A personality.

Certain preferences.

Certain beliefs.

Certain characteristics that distinguish me from other people.

These things provide continuity across changing circumstances.

But human life is not particularly respectful of permanent descriptions.

We grow older.

Our bodies change.

We develop new abilities.

Lose old interests.

Enter relationships.

Leave them.

Acquire responsibilities.

Discover that some of our convictions were mistaken.

And occasionally become people we would barely recognize from ten years earlier.

Under ordinary circumstances, these changes happen slowly enough that we can integrate them into a continuing story.

Alice has a more serious logistical problem.

Wonderland is compressing years of possible transformation into a single afternoon.

And demanding that she remain capable of explaining herself throughout.

The Body That No Longer Confirms the Story

Alice's most immediate difficulty is physical.

She keeps changing size.

Sometimes she is enormous.

Sometimes tiny.

Her familiar relationship with the world has become unreliable.

Objects that were once manageable become obstacles.

Distances change.

Her body no longer provides the predictable scale through which she understands her surroundings.

For Alice, this is not merely inconvenient.

It is disorienting.

We tend to imagine identity as something that happens inside the mind.

I remember my past.

I have beliefs.

I possess a personality.

Therefore, I know who I am.

But our experience of being ourselves also depends on the body.

We inhabit the world from a particular physical perspective.

We recognize our movements.

Anticipate what our limbs can do.

Understand distances in relation to our size.

Experience ourselves as located somewhere.

And maintain a largely automatic sense that the body through which we act belongs to us.

Research on bodily self-consciousness and the sense of agency explores how bodily signals, perception, and action contribute to this experience.

That does not mean identity can be reduced to height, appearance, or physical condition.

But it does mean that the body is not merely an accessory carried around by an otherwise complete psychological self.

Alice discovers this through an exceptionally imaginative disturbance.

Her body changes.

And suddenly her confidence in who she is changes with it.

She has not forgotten her name.

She has not lost every memory.

Yet the familiar experience of being Alice has become difficult to maintain.

The body that ordinarily confirms her sense of continuity is no longer cooperating.

The Caterpillar Who Is Surprisingly Unconcerned About Change

Alice attempts to explain her predicament by referring to the Caterpillar's own future.

One day, she points out, it will become a chrysalis.

Then a butterfly.

Surely such an extraordinary transformation must feel strange.

The Caterpillar disagrees.

It does not seem remotely concerned.

This is one of the scene's most interesting jokes.

Alice is explaining the difficulty of change to a creature whose biological life involves radical transformation.

And the creature finds her concern rather unimpressive.

There is an obvious temptation to interpret the Caterpillar as a miniature Zen master.

Alice worries about identity.

The Caterpillar calmly accepts transformation.

Perhaps the wise insect understands that all things change.

Perhaps Alice has encountered an enlightened teacher.

A pleasing interpretation.

But not a particularly faithful account of the conversation.

The Caterpillar is not consistently compassionate or helpful.

It is impatient, dismissive, sometimes contemptuous, and remarkably uninterested in making Alice feel understood.

Its apparent serenity may reflect wisdom.

It may also reflect the fact that another person's identity crisis is not especially interesting when one has a comfortable mushroom and a hookah.

Carroll leaves the distinction unresolved.

And that is useful.

We should not mistake emotional detachment for philosophical insight simply because the detached person speaks slowly.

Still, the Caterpillar presents Alice with a genuine challenge.

Why should transformation necessarily threaten identity?

A caterpillar becomes a butterfly.

Something changes profoundly.

Yet we can still describe a continuity between the stages.

Perhaps remaining oneself does not require remaining the same in every respect.

Perhaps the problem is not change itself.

Perhaps it is the expectation that change must always be experienced as a loss of identity.

Alice is not ready to accept such an answer.

In fairness, the Caterpillar has not offered it.

It has simply contradicted her.

Explain Yourself

The Caterpillar demands an explanation.

Alice cannot provide one.

There is a wonderful ambiguity in the phrase.

To explain oneself can mean describing what one means.

It can also mean justifying oneself.

And the second meaning is often considerably more emotionally demanding.

We are constantly asked to explain who we are.

Why did you make that decision?

Why do you feel that way?

Why have you changed?

Why don't you want what you used to want?

What sort of person behaves like this?

Sometimes these are useful questions.

They help us understand one another and take responsibility for our actions.

But they can also carry an impossible expectation.

That every change must be immediately available to conscious explanation.

That we should always possess a coherent story about ourselves.

That uncertainty about identity is evidence of some failure to know ourselves properly.

Alice encounters this demand at precisely the moment when her usual explanations have become inadequate.

She is confused.

The Caterpillar responds by requiring greater clarity.

Alice tries to explain why she cannot explain.

The explanation is rejected.

She attempts another approach.

It too is rejected.

The conversation becomes a miniature demonstration of how language can fail to provide the understanding it promises.

The question is supposed to clarify identity.

Instead, it intensifies Alice's uncertainty.

The demand to explain herself becomes one more thing she cannot do correctly.

When Memory Stops Supporting Identity

Alice's difficulties extend beyond her changing body.

She also reports that familiar things no longer come out as they should when she tries to remember them.

This is important.

Memory is one of the main ways we maintain a sense of continuity through time.

We know that today's self belongs to the same life as yesterday's because we can remember experiences, relationships, choices, and recurring features of our personal history.

Autobiographical memory helps us connect the person we were with the person we currently understand ourselves to be.

Psychological research distinguishes several dimensions of this continuity.

There is the immediate experience of being a subject.

The recognition of oneself as a person with particular characteristics.

And the sense of connection between past and present selves.

These dimensions are related, but they are not identical.

Alice's experience brings them into conflict.

She remembers who she was this morning.

But her current body is unfamiliar.

Her ordinary capacities seem unreliable.

And the person she remembers being no longer fits comfortably with the person having these experiences.

The Caterpillar responds with what resembles an examination.

It tells her to recite a familiar poem about Father William.

Alice attempts the recitation.

The result is an absurd parody, full of unexpected explanations, impossible behavior, and thoroughly unsuitable advice.

The Caterpillar declares the performance incorrect.

Alice reluctantly agrees that something has gone wrong.

The episode is comical partly because the attempt to test identity through familiar language produces more nonsense.

She reaches for a memorized text.

And the text has changed.

The words that should have provided evidence of continuity now become evidence of instability.

Yet an important distinction remains.

Alice's altered recitation is not a clinical demonstration of memory impairment.

Carroll is playing with Victorian didactic verse, parody, and the expectations associated with a child's education.

The psychological relevance lies in the scene's structure.

Alice tries to use a familiar ability to confirm that she is still herself.

The test fails.

And the failure makes the question of identity more urgent.

The Problem With Other People's Examinations

There is something almost cruel about the way the Caterpillar tests Alice.

It asks questions.

Rejects explanations.

Issues instructions.

And provides remarkably little assistance in understanding what counts as a satisfactory answer.

Alice is the one who must account for herself.

The Caterpillar assumes the authority to evaluate her.

But when Alice attempts to reverse the arrangement and asks the Caterpillar to identify itself first, the response is another question.

Why should it?

Alice cannot immediately explain.

The conversation collapses again.

This is a small but revealing reversal.

Alice has accepted that she owes the Caterpillar an explanation of her identity.

But when she asks for the same thing in return, the supposed obligation suddenly becomes questionable.

Why should either creature have to provide a definitive account of itself?

What exactly would count as a successful answer?

A name?

A biological classification?

A personal history?

A description of temperament?

The Caterpillar seems unconcerned by the need to define itself.

Alice experiences that need as urgent.

This difference is not necessarily evidence that the Caterpillar possesses a superior philosophy.

It may simply enjoy occupying the stronger conversational position.

But the scene exposes something recognizable about identity.

Sometimes we experience ourselves through questions posed by other people.

They ask us to explain.

We attempt to produce an acceptable account.

Their response influences whether the explanation feels convincing.

And gradually, the demand to be understandable can become entangled with the demand to be acceptable.

We are not merely trying to know ourselves.

We are trying to supply a version of ourselves that another person will recognize.

Alice's problem becomes especially frustrating because Wonderland's inhabitants refuse to cooperate with the ordinary rules of recognition.

She cannot rely on them to confirm what she already believes.

And she cannot easily persuade them to accept her uncertainty.

The Wonderful Uselessness of Being Told to Calm Down

At one point, the Caterpillar calls Alice back to deliver what sounds like important advice.

She returns, expecting something useful.

The advice is to control her temper.

An extraordinary contribution to the discussion.

Alice has been struggling with bodily transformation, unreliable memory, and the apparent collapse of ordinary conversation.

The Caterpillar has concluded that her emotional response requires correction.

This is another recognizably human situation.

Someone is confused or distressed.

We offer an instruction about how they should feel.

Calm down.

Stop worrying.

Be reasonable.

Don't overreact.

Sometimes emotional regulation genuinely helps us think more clearly.

But telling someone to remain calm does not automatically provide the information, security, or understanding they need.

And confusion does not become less confusing merely because irritation has been declared inappropriate.

The Caterpillar's advice is funny because it is both superficially sensible and almost completely unresponsive to Alice's actual predicament.

She needs help orienting herself.

She receives a lesson in manners.

Once again, the conversation imposes a social expectation instead of resolving the problem it supposedly addresses.

Alice is not only uncertain about who she is.

She must also remain sufficiently polite while explaining why she is uncertain.

An exhausting combination.

Three Inches Is a Perfectly Good Height

Eventually, the conversation turns toward Alice's size.

The Caterpillar asks what height she would prefer.

Alice explains that she is not especially particular about the exact measurement.

Her main difficulty is the constant changing.

Then she admits that being only three inches tall is unpleasant.

The Caterpillar becomes offended.

It happens to be exactly three inches tall.

And considers the height entirely satisfactory.

This is a delightful little lesson in the limitations of supposedly objective judgments.

Three inches is a measurement.

Whether three inches is a desirable height depends on the creature being measured and the circumstances in which it lives.

For Alice, the size is unfamiliar and restrictive.

For the Caterpillar, it is normal.

The physical quantity is the same.

The experience is different.

Yet each is tempted to treat its own perspective as authoritative.

Alice assumes that three inches is an inadequate size.

The Caterpillar treats that assumption almost as a personal insult.

Neither is simply inventing the situation.

Alice genuinely struggles with her altered body.

The Caterpillar genuinely inhabits a different bodily scale.

The absurdity arises when a local perspective becomes a universal judgment.

We do this constantly.

A particular lifestyle is normal.

A particular amount of money is enough.

A particular emotional response is appropriate.

A particular kind of person is successful.

The standards may be useful within certain contexts.

But we often forget how much depends on the person, environment, and expectations involved.

Alice's distress is not automatically invalid because the Caterpillar enjoys being small.

And the Caterpillar's satisfaction is not invalid because Alice dislikes the same height.

Perhaps the problem is not deciding which creature has the correct opinion.

Perhaps it is recognizing that the question has been organized around two different lives.

The Zen Question: Must the Self Have a Final Definition?

Now we can introduce the Zen-inspired perspective.

Not because Carroll was secretly writing a Buddhist teaching.

And not because the Caterpillar is a Zen master disguised as an unusually unpleasant conversational partner.

The nonsense in Alice's Adventures in Wonderland belongs to Carroll's literary world of logic, linguistic ambiguity, parody, and absurd social encounters.

Zen kōan practice belongs to a distinct religious and philosophical tradition, with its own discipline, methods, and aims.

The two should not be treated as interchangeable simply because both sometimes frustrate ordinary expectations.

But the conversation with the Caterpillar does offer a useful opportunity to examine our attachment to fixed descriptions of the self.

Zen Buddhist philosophy challenges the tendency to regard the self as an independent, permanent entity that can be fully captured through conceptual thought.

Its traditions examine the changing and interdependent nature of experience, not merely the intellectual difficulty of defining personality.

This does not mean that Zen denies ordinary personal identity or that a person should forget their name, history, and responsibilities.

The point is subtler.

We use descriptions of ourselves.

I am confident.

I am anxious.

I am successful.

I am someone who always takes responsibility.

I am the person I have always been.

These descriptions can be useful.

They organize memory and support ordinary life.

But they can also become restrictive when we treat them as permanent requirements.

A confident person may find it humiliating to admit fear.

A strong person may struggle to ask for help.

Someone who has always been the responsible one may not know how to refuse another obligation.

The identity begins governing experience rather than helping to describe it.

Alice's difficulty is that she can no longer make the old description fit.

A Zen-inspired question would not necessarily be how to recover the perfect formula.

It might be whether she needs a perfect formula in order to remain capable of living.

She is changing.

She is confused.

She still experiences the world.

She still acts.

Perhaps the self does not have to become a fixed object before any of that is possible.

The Difference Between Not Knowing and Not Existing

There is an important distinction here.

Alice cannot confidently explain who she is.

That does not mean she has ceased to exist.

She remains a subject of experience.

She has preferences.

Reactions.

Memories.

Concerns.

A sense of humor.

The ability to become irritated with an infuriating Caterpillar.

And a continuing desire to find her way through Wonderland.

Her self-description is unstable.

Her existence is not thereby erased.

This is psychologically significant because people sometimes confuse uncertainty about identity with the absence of identity.

I no longer know what kind of person I am.

I have changed.

My old ambitions no longer matter.

My relationships have altered.

The life I imagined no longer seems to fit.

These experiences can be genuinely painful.

Sometimes profound disturbances of identity are associated with clinical difficulties and deserve appropriate attention.

But ordinary changes in self-understanding are also part of development.

We do not need to maintain identical beliefs, preferences, bodies, or goals throughout life in order to experience continuity.

And continuity need not mean complete sameness.

Psychological research on self-continuity distinguishes between our connection to past and future versions of ourselves and the degree to which we experience those versions as similar.

The distinction matters.

We can recognize that the person we were ten years ago belongs to our history while also recognizing that we have changed considerably.

We can remain responsible for past actions without being permanently defined by them.

And we can imagine a future self who will understand some things differently.

Alice's problem is that the changes arrive faster than she can integrate them.

But the psychological task is not necessarily to stop changing.

It may be to develop enough flexibility to remain oriented while change continues.

The Mushroom That Provides No Philosophical Answer

At the end of the conversation, the Caterpillar finally offers something useful.

The mushroom.

Eating from one side will make Alice grow taller.

Eating from the other will make her shorter.

A practical solution.

Or almost.

The mushroom is round.

Alice must work out which side is which.

Even the instructions are less straightforward than they first appear.

But the important detail is what the Caterpillar does not provide.

It does not explain Alice's ultimate identity.

Does not tell her what kind of person she really is.

Does not resolve the philosophical problem of continuity through change.

It gives her a way to act.

Alice experiments.

The results are initially alarming.

But gradually she learns how to adjust her size.

She becomes more capable of navigating the world, even though the larger question of identity has not received a definitive answer.

I think this is the most interesting turn in the entire episode.

Alice arrives wanting to know how to understand herself.

She leaves with something closer to practical agency.

She can respond.

Experiment.

Observe consequences.

Make adjustments.

The world remains absurd.

Her identity remains complicated.

But she is no longer entirely helpless.

There is something psychologically important about the difference between needing a final explanation and developing the capacity to act amid uncertainty.

We often imagine that understanding must precede every meaningful change.

First I must know who I am.

Then I can decide what to do.

But sometimes the relationship works in the other direction.

We act.

Encounter consequences.

Discover preferences.

Develop capacities.

And gradually learn something about ourselves through participation in life.

Not every uncertainty can be resolved in advance.

And not every useful action requires a completed theory of identity.

A Question That Changes Depending on Who Is Asking

There is one final complication.

The question of identity is never entirely independent of the situation in which it is asked.

Who are you?

Asked by a friend, it may be an invitation to intimacy.

Asked by an official, it may require a document.

Asked by a therapist, it may open a discussion of self-understanding.

Asked by an employer, it may concern professional capabilities.

Asked by a hostile stranger, it can feel like a challenge.

The same words perform different social functions.

Alice's conversation with the Caterpillar is not simply a philosophical investigation.

It is also an encounter between two creatures negotiating authority, patience, etiquette, and the right to demand explanations.

The Caterpillar asks a question whose answer it does not seem particularly interested in helping Alice discover.

Alice tries to be polite while becoming increasingly irritated.

Both creatures repeatedly misunderstand what the other considers obvious.

And the conversation produces more confusion than clarity.

That is part of Carroll's achievement.

He shows how language can be perfectly grammatical while becoming almost useless as communication.

Every sentence seems understandable on its own.

The exchange as a whole is a disaster.

There is a psychological lesson here that does not require any elaborate spiritual interpretation.

Understanding another person involves more than asking precise questions.

It requires some willingness to recognize the experience from which they are answering.

Alice cannot explain herself because her familiar world has become unstable.

The Caterpillar responds as though the instability is either unimportant or entirely her problem.

The question is not necessarily wrong.

The conversation fails because the participants do not share an understanding of what the question requires.

Sometimes the most important part of a conversation is not the answer.

It is discovering what kind of answer the other person is actually asking for.

Perhaps Alice Doesn't Need to Know Yet

It would be easy to end this essay with an uplifting conclusion.

Alice discovers that identity is fluid.

The Caterpillar teaches her the wisdom of transformation.

She accepts change.

And everybody becomes psychologically enlightened.

Unfortunately, nothing in the scene supports such a tidy interpretation.

Alice remains confused.

The Caterpillar remains irritating.

The mushroom requires further experimentation.

And Wonderland shows no sign of becoming more reasonable.

This is precisely why the episode is so useful.

It does not resolve uncertainty through a beautiful philosophical formula.

It allows uncertainty to remain part of the experience.

Alice does not know exactly who she is.

But she knows that something has changed.

She knows that her body feels unfamiliar.

That her memory is not behaving as expected.

That the social rules she relied upon are no longer sufficient.

And that she still has to find a way to move through the world.

Perhaps this is closer to ordinary psychological life than the comforting idea that maturity means discovering one final, coherent description of ourselves.

We change.

Sometimes gradually.

Sometimes through events that make our previous identities difficult to inhabit.

We attempt to construct continuity.

We rely on memory.

The body.

Relationships.

Language.

The responses of people who know us.

These resources can help.

But none guarantees a completely fixed definition.

And perhaps they do not need to.

The problem is not that our descriptions change.

The problem begins when we insist that every change must immediately be resolved into another permanent description.

I used to be this kind of person.

Now I must discover what kind of person I am instead.

As though the purpose of personal development were to replace one rigid formula with another.

Carroll's Alice offers an alternative, even if she does not intend to.

She keeps moving.

Keeps asking questions.

Keeps discovering that the answers are incomplete.

And gradually learns how to respond to a world that refuses to behave according to her expectations.

The Zen-inspired question is not whether she has discovered the true self hidden beneath all her transformations.

It is whether she can stop demanding a perfectly stable answer before allowing herself to continue.

The Caterpillar's question remains.

Who are you?

Perhaps the most useful answer is not a definition.

Perhaps it is the recognition that the person being asked is still here, still experiencing, still changing, and still capable of acting.

A description of yourself may be useful. It does not have to become a condition for being yourself.

And perhaps the real difficulty is not that Alice keeps changing.

It is that she has been taught to believe she ought to know exactly who she is before she can decide what to do next.

A face appears beneath a translucent blue liquid.

Illustration supplied from the owner-authorized Psychology Notebook reserve.

Sources and further reading

Keep reading

Explore the writing archive →

Stay in touch

More essays and updates on ABVX Substack.

Read and subscribe on Substack →