
Cover image supplied from the owner-authorized Psychology Notebook reserve.
Think about your last birthday.
Perhaps you can remember the room, the people around you, the sound of their voices, or the way you felt when someone brought out the cake.
You might even experience a faint sense of being there again.
Now imagine remembering the same birthday in an entirely different way.
You know where you were. You know who attended. You know what happened.
But there's no scene to revisit.
No feeling of returning to that moment.
Just information.
It's rather like knowing the plot of a film you've never actually watched.
And for some people, this is how nearly their entire personal past exists.
Knowing Isn't the Same as Remembering
Autobiographical memory contains different kinds of information.
One involves facts about our lives.
Where we went to school. Who our friends were. Where we lived. What happened during a particular holiday.
This is autobiographical semantic memory.
Another involves the subjective experience of remembering a particular episode, including details of time, place, perception, and emotion.
This is episodic autobiographical memory.
The remarkable thing is that these abilities can come apart.
In 2015, Daniela Palombo, Brian Levine, and their colleagues described three otherwise healthy adults with Severely Deficient Autobiographical Memory, or SDAM.
These individuals could learn, work, maintain relationships, and remember factual information.
But they reported a lifelong inability to vividly re-experience personal events from a first-person perspective.
They knew their own histories.
They just couldn't mentally travel back into them.
A Life Without Mental Time Travel
Psychologists use the term mental time travel to describe our ability to mentally revisit past experiences and imagine possible future ones.
For many people, remembering involves reconstructing a scene.
Not necessarily with photographic accuracy, because memory is reconstructive rather than a perfect recording.
But with some subjective sense of having experienced it.
For someone with SDAM, that feeling may be greatly diminished or absent.
They might remember getting married without being able to mentally return to the ceremony.
They may know that a holiday was wonderful without being able to re-experience a particular afternoon.
And imagining the future may be difficult in a similar way.
Not because they lack plans or ambitions.
But because constructing a vivid scene of something that hasn't happened may rely partly on processes also involved in reconstructing the past.
They can have a personal history without being able to mentally step back inside it.
What About the Mind's Eye?
There's another fascinating connection.
Some people cannot voluntarily generate visual mental images.
This is known as aphantasia.
Ask them to imagine an apple, and they may understand exactly what an apple looks like without seeing any image in their mind.
Research has found associations between aphantasia and less vivid autobiographical memories, as well as differences in imagining future events.
Some studies also report differences in dream imagery.
But aphantasia and SDAM are not the same thing.
Not everyone with aphantasia has SDAM, and the relationship between them is still being investigated.
The hippocampus, visual association areas, and other regions participate in reconstructing autobiographical experiences.
Research has identified differences in the activity or connectivity of some of these regions in people with unusually weak autobiographical recollection or visual imagery.
But there isn't one established neurological defect that explains every case.
And we certainly cannot conclude that someone has SDAM simply because they don't visualise memories.
Is Something Missing?
Here's where the psychological question becomes interesting.
We tend to assume that our past exists inside us as a collection of experiences we can revisit.
That remembering something important means being able to feel it again.
But what if your relationship with the past is organised differently?
You can still know what matters to you.
You can still understand your relationships, recognise your achievements, learn from mistakes, and maintain a sense of personal identity.
The original SDAM cases demonstrated that significant differences in subjective recollection can coexist with otherwise preserved cognitive functioning.
Of course, changes in memory can also occur with depression, trauma-related conditions, neurological illness, and many other causes. Sudden or progressive memory difficulties deserve clinical assessment.
But lifelong SDAM should not automatically be explained as repressed trauma or a damaged hippocampus.
Its causes remain uncertain.
And perhaps that's the most interesting part.
We often imagine that everyone experiences memory in roughly the same way.
But the human mind may be considerably more diverse than our own experience allows us to appreciate.
Some people remember their lives as experiences they can revisit. Others remember them as stories they know to be true.
And both are ways of having a past.
Perhaps memory isn't only about what happened to us.
It's also about the very different ways our minds allow us to know that it happened.
Framework and scope
This article is educational and does not offer a self-diagnostic test. Findings about dream imagery and hippocampal-occipital connectivity in aphantasia cannot automatically be generalised to everyone with SDAM. Lifelong SDAM is distinct from acquired or progressive memory problems.
References
- Palombo et al. (2015), Severely Deficient Autobiographical Memory (SDAM) in Healthy Adults: A New Mnemonic Syndrome
- Conti et al. (2023), Lifelong Impairment in Episodic Re-Experiencing
- Dawes et al. (2020), A Cognitive Profile of Multi-Sensory Imagery, Memory and Dreaming in Aphantasia
- Monzel et al. (2024), Hippocampal-Occipital Connectivity Reflects Autobiographical Memory Deficits in Aphantasia
