
Cover image supplied from the owner-authorized Psychology Notebook reserve.
Jim Jarmusch, Zen Buddhism, and the Psychology of Being Together
Nothing particularly important happens in Jim Jarmusch's Coffee and Cigarettes.
People sit at tables. They drink coffee. They smoke. They discuss things that probably didn't need discussing.
Sometimes they misunderstand each other. Sometimes they're uncomfortable. Sometimes they seem perfectly happy to be somewhere else.
And occasionally, against all reasonable expectations, something genuinely human happens.
It's a rather extraordinary achievement for a film that spends almost its entire running time refusing to go anywhere.
Hollywood usually requires a story to have a purpose.
Jarmusch seems perfectly comfortable with the possibility that a conversation might not.
And this raises an interesting question.
Why do we find it so difficult to spend time with another person without trying to make something happen?
The Terrible Suspicion That Nothing Is Happening
In one of the film's episodes, two men, played by Isaach De Bankolé and Alex Descas, meet for coffee.
One assumes the other must have invited him for a particular reason.
Some important information. A request. Something to discuss.
But there isn't anything.
And the absence of a reason becomes the subject of their entire conversation.
Which is wonderfully absurd.
And also rather familiar.
We're so accustomed to meetings having an objective that simply spending time together can feel vaguely suspicious.
Why did you want to see me?
What do you need?
Is there something you're not telling me?
Perhaps the most unsettling possibility is that the other person simply wanted to see us.
No transaction.
No hidden agenda.
No opportunity to demonstrate our usefulness.
Just two people sharing a little time.
Apparently, that's a remarkably complicated social arrangement.
The Ego Orders Another Coffee
Consider another episode.
Alfred Molina meets Steve Coogan and enthusiastically reveals that they may be distant relatives.
Molina sees the discovery as an opportunity for genuine connection.
Coogan is considerably less enthusiastic.
The social hierarchy is too obvious. One man is eager to establish closeness, while the other seems preoccupied with maintaining his status.
Until the possibility of a more prestigious connection changes the calculation.
Suddenly, the relationship looks rather more interesting.
It's a beautiful miniature of what psychology calls social evaluation.
We don't simply encounter other people.
We evaluate them, compare ourselves with them, and wonder what the encounter might mean for our own identity.
Am I important?
Am I being respected?
Do they admire me?
Should I appear more successful, less interested, more intelligent, or considerably busier than I actually am?
The exhausting thing about all this is that we're no longer entirely present in the conversation.
Part of our attention is occupied with managing the impression we're making.
The other person becomes an audience.
And we become a performance.
Sometimes we spend so much effort trying to appear interesting that we forget to become interested.
What Zen Has to Do With Two People Drinking Coffee
At first glance, Coffee and Cigarettes has surprisingly little to do with Buddhism.
Nobody seems particularly enlightened.
There are no monasteries, no meditation cushions, and certainly no shortage of unnecessary talking.
But there is an interesting parallel with one of the central practices of Soto Zen: shikantaza, often translated as just sitting.
In this tradition, sitting meditation isn't simply another technique for obtaining a desirable psychological result.
It's a practice of being present without constantly turning the experience into a project.
The ordinary moment doesn't need to become something more impressive to deserve our attention.
And Dogen's tradition extends this attitude beyond formal meditation into ordinary daily activities.
Cooking. Cleaning. Walking.
Perhaps even sitting at a table with another human being who has absolutely nothing useful to tell us.
This doesn't mean that smoking a cigarette is a form of meditation.
Nicotine isn't enlightenment, and Jarmusch's film is hardly a public health recommendation.
Nor is Zen simply an instruction to relax, stop caring, or enjoy a fashionable minimalist lifestyle.
But the philosophical parallel is interesting.
What if a moment doesn't need to achieve anything in order to be worth experiencing?
What if we could sit with someone without attempting to improve the conversation?
Without needing to be admired?
Without treating every silence as a technical problem requiring immediate repair?
This may sound simple.
Until you actually try it.
The Psychology of Awkward Silence
Silence is a peculiar thing.
On your own, it can be peaceful.
In the company of another person, three seconds of silence can sometimes feel like an international diplomatic incident.
Psychological models of social anxiety describe how people can become intensely focused on monitoring their own behaviour during social encounters.
Am I saying the right thing?
Do I look uncomfortable?
Why haven't they replied?
Should I say something clever?
This self-focused attention can make it harder to notice what the other person is actually communicating.
And even outside clinical social anxiety, many of us recognise a milder version of this experience.
Instead of listening, we're preparing our next line.
Instead of observing, we're evaluating.
Instead of being in a conversation, we're watching ourselves having one.
Jarmusch makes these tiny negotiations visible.
A glance lasts too long.
A compliment arrives at the wrong moment.
Someone says something intended to establish intimacy, and the other person responds as though they've received an unexpected tax demand.
The discomfort is funny precisely because we recognise it.
These people aren't necessarily bad at communicating.
They're often too busy protecting their identities to risk actual contact.
The Coffee Cup as a Psychological Defense
There's something else worth noticing.
Almost everyone has something to do with their hands.
A cup to hold.
A cigarette to light.
An ashtray to rearrange.
A small, familiar ritual to occupy the space between words.
Psychological research suggests that rituals can help regulate emotions and organise social interactions.
And ordinary routines can sometimes provide a sense of structure when a situation feels uncertain.
Of course, not every repeated gesture is a ritual in the scientific sense.
Still, the film offers an intriguing visual metaphor.
When human contact becomes uncomfortable, we return to something manageable.
We stir the coffee.
Look for a lighter.
Take another sip.
The objects give us something to do while we work out what to do with each other.
Sometimes this helps the conversation continue.
Sometimes it allows us to avoid the conversation entirely.
And here we meet a familiar psychological distinction.
The same behaviour can support connection or provide an escape from it.
What matters isn't simply the action.
It's the function the action serves.
Two People, Two Versions of Reality
In another episode, Cate Blanchett plays both a successful actress and her resentful cousin.
They share a face.
But they inhabit very different psychological worlds.
One brings fame, opportunity, and a certain social distance.
The other carries envy, frustration, and an acute awareness of their unequal positions.
They speak to one another, but much of what happens between them is filtered through their separate identities.
Each is responding partly to the person across the table and partly to what that person represents.
This is where the film becomes particularly interesting from a psychological perspective.
We rarely meet someone without bringing our expectations along.
Previous experiences shape what we notice.
Our insecurities influence how we interpret ambiguous remarks.
Our identities determine which parts of an encounter feel threatening.
We don't simply hear what someone says.
We also hear what we fear they might mean.
Zen practice invites a different relationship with these automatic interpretations.
Not pretending that we have no past or personality.
But noticing the thoughts and judgements that arise without necessarily treating them as the entire reality of the moment.
The other person might actually be different from the character we've already assigned them.
Which is a surprisingly inconvenient possibility.
The Beauty of an Unproductive Moment
One of the film's most moving episodes comes near the end.
Two older men, played by Taylor Mead and Bill Rice, share a break in a rather unremarkable setting.
They imagine their coffee as champagne and raise a toast to vanished cultural worlds.
Paris in the 1920s.
New York in the late 1970s.
There is no grand revelation.
No impressive achievement.
No life-changing conversation.
Just two people, an ordinary moment, a little imagination, and the melancholy of time passing.
And somehow, after all the awkward performances and uncomfortable encounters we've watched, this moment feels unusually complete.
Perhaps because nobody seems especially concerned with proving anything.
They don't need to be more successful.
More interesting.
More important.
They're simply there.
It would be too much to call this enlightenment.
But there's a quiet beauty in a moment that doesn't seem to demand anything beyond being experienced.
Not Every Moment Needs a Purpose
We live in a culture that has become exceptionally good at turning almost everything into an opportunity for improvement.
Walks are for fitness.
Reading is for personal development.
Conversations are for networking.
Rest is for optimising future productivity.
Even meditation can become another project in which we monitor our progress towards becoming sufficiently calm.
We've managed to turn the absence of activity into another activity to perform correctly.
Jarmusch offers a rather amusing alternative.
Eleven small encounters.
People being awkward, defensive, vain, lonely, generous, suspicious, and occasionally affectionate.
Nothing is resolved particularly efficiently.
And yet, something is revealed.
We spend enormous amounts of effort trying to control how other people perceive us.
We protect ourselves from uncomfortable silences.
We interpret, compare, defend, and perform.
All while the actual encounter quietly passes us by.
Psychology helps explain some of these habits.
Zen encourages us to notice our attachment to them.
And Jarmusch gives us ninety-five minutes to watch what happens when people fail, sometimes magnificently, to escape themselves.
Perhaps the lesson isn't that we should stop talking.
Or stop thinking.
Or abandon ambition and spend the rest of our lives in cafés.
It's simply that not every human encounter needs to produce a result.
Sometimes the most meaningful thing we can offer another person is our attention, without turning the moment into a performance.
A conversation doesn't always need a conclusion.
A silence doesn't always need an explanation.
And a cup of coffee doesn't always need to become a metaphor for the meaning of existence.
Although, admittedly, we've just spent an entire essay doing exactly that.
Framework and scope
The Zen reading offered here is the author’s interpretation, not evidence that Jarmusch intended a Buddhist teaching. Zen is not merely relaxation, passivity or an absence of thought. Awkwardness is not a diagnosis, and holding a cup or smoking does not by itself establish a psychological defense. Rituals depend on their context and function. The film’s scenes illustrate possibilities rather than proving psychological mechanisms; research on clinical social anxiety in adolescents does not diagnose its adult characters. Tobacco use is not a mindfulness practice or a recommendation.
References
- Jim Jarmusch (2003), American Film Institute: Coffee and Cigarettes
- Scott Macaulay (2004; republished by Focus Features in 2009), Brief Encounters: Jim Jarmusch on Coffee and Cigarettes
- Soto Zen Buddhist Association, What Is Zazen?
- Hobson et al. (2018), The Psychology of Rituals: An Integrative Review and Process-Based Framework
- Leigh & Clark (2018), Understanding Social Anxiety Disorder in Adolescents and Improving Treatment Outcomes
