A close-up photograph of a textured artwork depicting a face with theatrical makeup.

Cover image supplied from the owner-authorized Psychology Notebook reserve.

Martin Page, Zen Buddhism, and the Psychology of Getting Out of Your Own Head

There is a particular kind of misery reserved for people who think too much.

They understand why their job is absurd, why society is ridiculous, why their relationships are complicated, and why the things that make everyone else happy probably shouldn't.

They can explain almost anything.

Except how to enjoy an ordinary Tuesday.

French writer Martin Page built an entire novel around this unfortunate condition.

In How I Became Stupid (Comment je suis devenu stupide), his protagonist Antoine reaches a rather logical conclusion.

Intelligence makes him miserable.

Stupid people seem happy.

Therefore, the solution is obvious.

He needs to become an idiot.

And, being an intellectual, he approaches this project with considerable seriousness.

The Brilliant Idea of Becoming Stupid

Antoine is a young man burdened with curiosity, sensitivity, and an extraordinary talent for noticing everything that's wrong with the world.

Unfortunately, noticing problems isn't the same as being able to live with them.

He envies people who seem perfectly comfortable with consumerism, conventional success, and the reassuring simplicity of not questioning anything too deeply.

So he experiments with ways of escaping his intelligence.

Alcohol. Medication. The pursuit of wealth. The pleasures of becoming a respectable member of a society he previously found absurd.

Eventually, he discovers that the financial world can reward someone who has stopped asking particularly complicated questions.

Which is one of the book's more entertaining observations about modern civilisation.

But underneath the satire lies a serious psychological question.

What if the problem isn't how much you understand, but what your understanding is doing to you?

Zen Has a Rather Different Idea of Stupidity

At first glance, Zen Buddhism seems to offer advice rather similar to Antoine's plan.

Stop thinking so much.

Stop analysing everything.

Be here, now.

Preferably somewhere with a beautiful Japanese garden and absolutely no emails.

But Zen doesn't teach intellectual stupidity.

One of its central ideas, especially in the tradition associated with Shunryu Suzuki, is shoshin, or beginner's mind.

It means approaching experience with openness, curiosity, and fewer rigid assumptions about what we already know.

The beginner isn't someone who lacks intelligence.

The beginner is someone whose intelligence hasn't completely imprisoned their perception.

This is a rather important distinction.

A person can know a tremendous amount about relationships and still be unable to experience intimacy without analysing it.

They can understand every theory of happiness while remaining permanently dissatisfied.

They can study mindfulness for fifteen years and become terribly upset when someone meditates incorrectly.

Knowledge is useful.

But knowledge can also become another identity to defend.

And Zen invites us to notice something that Antoine has overlooked.

You don't necessarily need fewer thoughts. You may simply need to stop treating every thought as something that requires your participation.

Psychology Has a Name for Some of This

Modern psychology offers another interesting perspective.

Researchers studying rumination have found that repetitive negative thinking can intensify distress, interfere with problem-solving, and make it harder to move towards useful action.

The problem isn't thinking itself.

It's getting caught in the same mental loop without gaining anything new.

Imagine someone who has spent three hours analysing why their life isn't working.

They've reviewed their childhood, identified their attachment patterns, reconsidered their career choices, and developed a rather impressive theory of their own psychological dysfunction.

By the end of the evening, they're exhausted.

And they still haven't washed the dishes.

This is not necessarily insight.

Sometimes it's distress wearing the rather convincing costume of intellectual productivity.

Acceptance and Commitment Therapy introduces another useful concept: cognitive defusion.

Instead of treating every thought as an objective description of reality, we learn to notice it as a mental event.

I'm a failure.

Becomes:

I'm having the thought that I'm a failure.

Nothing magical has happened.

The thought is still there.

But a little distance has appeared between the thought and the person experiencing it.

And that distance can make room for something remarkably unfamiliar.

Choice.

The Problem with Being the Smartest Person in the Room

There's another complication worth considering.

Intelligence can become an identity.

Not simply something we use, but something we believe we must continuously demonstrate.

We become the person who sees through illusions.

The person who understands why everything is wrong.

The person who cannot possibly enjoy something ordinary because we understand its limitations too well.

There's a certain comfort in this position.

If I can explain why something is disappointing, I don't have to risk being disappointed by it.

If I can analyse love, I don't necessarily have to become vulnerable enough to experience it.

If I already know that something won't work, I can avoid the uncomfortable business of trying.

Being clever becomes a sophisticated form of self-protection.

Of course, intelligence and critical thinking aren't psychological disorders. And many things Antoine criticises in his world genuinely deserve criticism.

The point isn't to stop recognising absurdity.

It's to notice when our ability to recognise absurdity has become the only way we know how to relate to life.

Sometimes being right becomes more important than being alive to what is happening.

The Extraordinary Effort of Doing Nothing

Here's where Martin Page and Zen meet in an unexpected way.

Antoine wants to escape his suffering by becoming someone else.

Someone simpler.

Someone less aware.

Someone who can enjoy the ordinary rewards of society without constantly questioning them.

But the desire to become stupid is itself another elaborate intellectual construction.

Another project.

Another attempt to control his inner experience.

He doesn't want to stop struggling.

He wants to win the struggle by permanently eliminating the part of himself that struggles.

Zen suggests a different possibility.

What if the struggle itself doesn't always require a solution?

What if a thought can appear without becoming a command?

What if disappointment can be felt without turning into a theory about the meaninglessness of existence?

What if we can recognise the absurdity of consumer culture and still enjoy a decent cup of coffee?

This isn't indifference.

Nor is it an excuse to ignore real problems, injustice, or suffering.

It's a different relationship with experience.

Less compulsive interpretation.

More direct participation.

And perhaps the rather unsettling discovery that life doesn't always require our commentary.

You Don't Have to Become an Idiot

This is what makes Page's novel more interesting than a simple joke about smart people being unhappy.

Antoine believes he has two options.

Remain intelligent and miserable.

Or become stupid and happy.

Zen and psychology suggest that the problem may lie partly in the choice itself.

You can remain curious without turning curiosity into constant anxiety.

You can think critically without needing to criticise every moment of your existence.

You can understand your emotional patterns without analysing every feeling until it disappears beneath an avalanche of explanations.

And you can recognise that life is complicated without insisting on resolving every complication before allowing yourself to enjoy it.

There is a world of difference between refusing to think and no longer being controlled by thinking.

Perhaps Antoine doesn't need to become stupid at all.

Perhaps he needs to discover that his intelligence is a tool, not a permanent obligation.

That he can use it when it's useful.

And occasionally put it down.

Because the opposite of overthinking isn't stupidity. It's the freedom to experience something without immediately turning it into another problem to solve.

And if you can manage that, you might finally be able to enjoy an ordinary Tuesday.

Even if you know perfectly well how absurd Tuesdays are.

Framework and scope

The parallel between Page’s fiction, Zen and psychological flexibility is an interpretive comparison, not a claim that Zen or ACT historically influenced the novel. Zen and cognitive defusion are not identical theories or practices. Rumination is not intelligence, sensitivity, introspection or thoughtful reflection; fictional experiments with alcohol and medication are not clinical evidence. Beginner’s mind does not mean ignorance, emotional numbing or abandoning critical thought, and flexibility does not require accepting harm.

References

Keep reading

Explore the writing archive →

Stay in touch

More essays and updates on ABVX Substack.

Read and subscribe on Substack →