
Cover image supplied from the owner-authorized image reserve.
Emir Kusturica, the psychology of collective myths, and the difference between celebrating life and drowning out the truth.
Contains spoilers for Underground (1995). Discusses war, political manipulation, violence, and loss.
There is something reassuring about a wedding.
People gather.
The music begins.
Someone starts drinking considerably earlier than medical professionals would recommend.
Relatives embrace.
Old disagreements are temporarily forgotten.
And for a few hours, the world appears to have been organized around a perfectly reasonable principle.
We are alive.
We are together.
There is food.
Somebody should play another song.
This is one of the more attractive human responses to existence.
The world is complicated.
History is cruel.
People suffer and die.
Yet we can still gather around a table and celebrate the fact that life continues.
A beautiful thought.
Unfortunately, Emir Kusturica's Underground introduces a rather serious complication.
What if the party never stops?
What if the music continues through betrayal, violence, political manipulation, and the destruction of an entire country?
What if people dance so enthusiastically that they no longer notice who is controlling the room?
And what if the person arranging the celebration has been lying to them about the world outside?
Kusturica's 1995 film is a spectacular collision of music, alcohol, friendship, sex, war, political mythology, and historical catastrophe.
Almost everything is excessive.
People drink too much.
Shout too loudly.
Love too desperately.
Betray one another extravagantly.
And celebrate at moments when celebration seems wildly inappropriate.
It is easy to describe this as a film about the irrepressible vitality of life.
A world in which people refuse to surrender joy, even under impossible circumstances.
And there is truth in that interpretation.
But the film is also about an elaborate deception.
For decades, people live in an underground cellar believing that the Second World War is still taking place above them.
Their friend Marko knows the war has ended.
He has every opportunity to tell them.
Instead, he preserves the illusion because it makes him powerful.
The people below continue working.
The celebrations continue.
The years pass.
And the world they believe they inhabit increasingly ceases to correspond to the world outside.
This makes Underground much more than a film about surviving through joy.
It asks whether our most intense celebrations bring us into contact with life, or sometimes protect us from recognizing what is actually happening to it.
A Brass Band at the End of the World
Kusturica does not enter history quietly.
His film begins in Belgrade in 1941, just before the German invasion of Yugoslavia.
Marko and his friend Blacky are men of extraordinary appetites.
They drink.
Fight.
Pursue women.
Make money through dubious activities.
And appear almost constitutionally incapable of approaching anything with moderation.
Then the bombs arrive.
The world begins falling apart.
But the film's energy barely slows.
There are animals escaping from the zoo.
Confusion.
Violence.
Lovers.
Arguments.
And music that seems capable of continuing through virtually any catastrophe.
The soundtrack by Goran Bregović is essential to this experience.
Brass instruments push the film forward with a furious energy that can feel celebratory, aggressive, exhilarating, and exhausting at the same time.
The music does not politely retreat whenever something terrible happens.
It frequently intensifies the emotional contradiction.
We are watching disaster.
Yet the sound insists on movement.
The body wants to respond.
The rhythm carries us.
And this creates a problem for the viewer.
We are not simply observing people who turn suffering into a celebration.
The film encourages us to experience some of that celebration ourselves.
The music is magnificent.
The scenes are full of life.
And then we remember what is happening.
People are being killed.
A country is being invaded.
Political opportunists are taking advantage of disaster.
The vitality is genuine.
So is the horror.
Kusturica refuses to separate them neatly.
And that refusal produces both the film's extraordinary power and some of its deepest ethical difficulties.
When Celebration Really Does Help
Before examining the darker side of Kusturica's festivities, it is important to recognize something obvious.
Celebration is not inherently a denial of suffering.
People gather for weddings during difficult historical periods.
Sing at funerals.
Share food after disasters.
Dance when the future is uncertain.
Tell jokes in hospital rooms.
These activities can create connection.
They can provide temporary relief from distress.
They can remind people that their lives contain relationships and pleasures that have not been entirely destroyed by what is happening around them.
Psychological research on collective gatherings describes a phenomenon sometimes called collective effervescence or perceived emotional synchrony.
When people share attention, rhythm, movement, and emotion, they may experience a heightened sense of belonging and connection.
Research has associated these experiences with stronger collective identity, social integration, positive emotion, and perceived empowerment.
This does not mean that every gathering is beneficial or that collective excitement always supports sound judgment.
But it explains why shared celebration can matter so much.
A brass band is not merely producing noise.
The musicians and dancers participate in a common rhythm.
People experience themselves as part of something larger than their immediate individual concerns.
For someone living through danger or loss, that sense of connection can be valuable.
The group becomes a resource.
The celebration says something that a philosophical argument might struggle to communicate.
You are not alone.
We are still here.
Life has not become exclusively the disaster that surrounds us.
This is the generous side of Kusturica's cinema.
The music and excess can express resilience.
But Underground asks us to consider what happens when the same mechanism serves a very different purpose.
The Basement Where the War Never Ends
The film's central deception begins during the Second World War.
Marko hides Blacky and a group of resistance fighters in a cellar.
The underground community produces weapons.
The arrangement initially belongs to a recognizable wartime reality.
People are in danger.
They need shelter.
The struggle against occupation requires secrecy and resources.
But the war ends.
Belgrade is liberated.
Yugoslavia enters a new political period under Tito.
And Marko continues telling the people in the cellar that the war is still going on.
For approximately twenty years, the deception remains in place.
The people below manufacture weapons.
Marko profits from their work.
He advances within the political system above ground.
And he keeps Blacky away from Natalija, the woman both men desire.
There is something almost absurdly efficient about the arrangement.
One person controls the information.
The others control the production.
The person who knows what is happening enjoys freedom and political influence.
The people who do not know continue sacrificing their lives for a cause whose immediate circumstances have fundamentally changed.
The deception is not a small misunderstanding.
It is the structure of their existence.
Their work depends on it.
Their sense of duty depends on it.
Their understanding of the outside world depends on it.
And their loyalty to Marko helps keep the system operating.
This is where a purely psychological reading becomes insufficient.
The cellar is not merely a metaphor for people refusing to face uncomfortable truths.
It is also a political economy of manufactured ignorance.
Someone benefits materially from the lie.
Someone controls the means through which the lie is maintained.
And other people bear the consequences.
The Difference Between Self-Deception and Being Deceived
We often describe people who believe false stories as though the problem were entirely inside their minds.
They are gullible.
They need comforting explanations.
They do not want to see reality.
Perhaps they have become too attached to a particular version of events.
Sometimes these descriptions identify genuine psychological processes.
But they can also conceal the conditions under which a belief was formed.
The people in Marko's cellar do not possess equal access to information.
They cannot simply consult an independent newspaper or walk outside without consequences.
Their environment is controlled.
The apparent evidence of continuing war is manufactured.
Their dependence is exploited.
And the person they trust has arranged matters so that trusting him produces an increasingly false understanding of reality.
This is not simply a failure of individual critical thinking.
It is an unequal relationship of power.
The distinction matters beyond the film.
People may hold false beliefs because they are psychologically invested in them.
They may also hold them because reliable information has been deliberately withheld.
Because alternatives are punished.
Because a trusted institution has falsified the evidence.
Or because their material survival depends on participating in a system they cannot independently verify.
These explanations can overlap.
But they should not be confused.
It would be absurd to blame the cellar's inhabitants for failing to understand a historical situation that someone has systematically prevented them from observing.
The more interesting question concerns how trust and loyalty can be turned into instruments of domination.
Marko does not merely tell a lie.
He creates a world in which the lie is continuously supported by the circumstances of everyday life.
The Man Who Owns the Present
There is a particularly disturbing aspect of Marko's control.
He does not merely manipulate the past.
He manipulates the present.
The inhabitants of the cellar believe themselves to be living during a continuing war.
Outside, political history has moved forward.
New institutions have emerged.
The wartime resistance has become part of a state-sponsored heroic narrative.
Marko himself has moved from criminal opportunism to political prominence.
But beneath the ground, time has been artificially suspended.
The inhabitants continue acting according to an outdated account of reality.
They believe their sacrifices still belong to the struggle that originally justified them.
There is something psychologically profound about this.
Our understanding of the present depends partly on the stories through which we connect it with the past.
A person who believes they are still in danger will behave differently from someone who knows that the immediate danger has ended.
A community that believes the war continues will organize its work, loyalties, and priorities differently from one that knows peace has arrived.
Marko controls the narrative.
Therefore, he controls what the inhabitants believe their present responsibilities to be.
And because those responsibilities shape behavior, he can convert false beliefs into real labor.
The lie produces consequences.
Weapons are manufactured.
Families are raised.
Years pass.
People grow older.
The imaginary war has become an actual structure of everyday life.
The cellar is not outside history.
It is part of history, organized by somebody else's fabricated version of it.
The Wedding That Takes Place Inside a Lie
One of the film's extraordinary sequences is the underground wedding of Blacky's son Jovan and Jelena.
It contains almost everything associated with Kusturica's cinematic world.
A crowded space.
Music.
Drinking.
Romance.
An elaborate spectacle.
A bride who seems to float through the air.
People experiencing a moment of overwhelming collective significance.
A wedding is supposed to celebrate the beginning of a shared future.
The participants gather to recognize a relationship and the life that might grow from it.
But here the future is being celebrated inside a false account of the present.
Jovan has grown up underground.
He has never known the world that exists above him.
His understanding of history has been shaped by the adults around him.
And those adults have themselves been deceived.
The celebration is real.
The affection may be real.
The excitement is certainly real.
But the world within which the event receives its meaning has been carefully falsified.
This creates a difficult distinction.
Can a genuine emotion occur within a false story?
Of course.
People can love one another while misunderstanding important things about their circumstances.
A child can experience happiness in a community founded upon deception.
A wedding can bring people together even when the political narrative that organizes their lives is false.
The emotions do not become imaginary simply because the information is unreliable.
But neither does the authenticity of the emotions make the larger situation acceptable.
The wedding is joyful.
The captivity remains captivity.
And perhaps the most disturbing possibility is that the genuine joy helps the fabricated world continue.
Why question the foundations of a life that still contains love, music, and celebrations?
The Comfort of a Story Everyone Knows
A collective myth is not simply a false statement repeated by many people.
It can become a way of organizing relationships and identities.
Who are we?
What have we endured?
Who are our heroes?
Who betrayed us?
What do we owe to the past?
What sacrifices give meaning to our present?
Shared stories help communities answer these questions.
They are not inherently deceptive.
A historical narrative can preserve genuine experiences and create valuable continuity.
But a narrative can also become resistant to correction.
Especially when belonging depends on accepting it.
In the cellar, the story is clear.
The war continues.
The people below are participating in the struggle.
Marko is their connection with the outside world.
Their sacrifices matter because the struggle matters.
The narrative provides purpose.
The work confirms the narrative.
And the group's emotional life reinforces its coherence.
The problem is not that the people possess a shared story.
Human communities need shared understandings.
The problem is that they have been denied the ability to revise that story in response to reality.
Their sense of belonging is inseparable from an information structure controlled by someone who profits from keeping it false.
A community can be emotionally united while epistemically trapped.
Everyone agrees.
Everyone sings.
Everyone recognizes the same heroes.
The collective certainty is impressive.
Unfortunately, certainty is not evidence that the story is true.
Sometimes it is evidence that the conditions for disagreement have disappeared.
When the Film Set Becomes Another Battlefield
Eventually, the boundary between the underground and the outside world breaks.
Blacky and Jovan emerge.
They encounter a film production reconstructing the German occupation.
But because they still believe the Second World War is underway, they interpret the actors and staging as part of the continuing conflict.
A performance becomes indistinguishable from an event.
The result is violence.
This sequence is an extraordinary piece of filmmaking because it places several kinds of fiction on top of one another.
We are watching a film.
Inside that film, characters encounter another film being made.
But those characters interpret the fictional reconstruction as historical reality.
Their mistake is not simply that they are foolish.
They possess a worldview that has been maintained through decades of deception.
Within that worldview, the sight of German soldiers is meaningful.
The apparent evidence fits the story they have been taught.
And they act.
The joke is terrible because the consequences are real within the film.
People die because the distinction between historical reality and staged representation has collapsed.
This is where Kusturica's treatment of cinema becomes especially self-conscious.
Film can preserve memory.
Reconstruct the past.
Create national heroes.
And make an audience feel that it has encountered history directly.
But a representation is not the event itself.
It is constructed.
Framed.
Edited.
Performed.
And often produced under the influence of particular institutions and interests.
The characters who mistake the set for a battlefield dramatize a danger the film itself cannot completely escape.
We may become so accustomed to a particular representation of history that we stop examining the distinction between the representation and the history it claims to show.
The Political Reality Beneath the Music
This is why Underground cannot be reduced to a universal psychological parable.
The film is about Yugoslavia.
It begins during the Nazi invasion and occupation in 1941.
Moves through the partisan struggle and the socialist period under Josip Broz Tito.
And eventually reaches the violent breakup of Yugoslavia during the wars of the 1990s.
Its narrative addresses political power, official heroism, the manufacture of historical memory, profiteering, and the destruction of a shared state.
The film was released in 1995, while war in Bosnia and Herzegovina was still shaping the lives of real people.
That context matters.
The suffering was not an abstract symbol.
The political arguments were not merely philosophical disagreements about collective identity.
Different communities were confronting violence, displacement, atrocities, and competing accounts of responsibility.
Kusturica's film became controversial partly because critics disagreed about how it represented that history.
Some argued that its extravagant style, nostalgic vision of Yugoslavia, and treatment of violence risked obscuring particular political responsibilities or reproducing stereotypes about the Balkans as a place of endless irrational passion.
Others interpreted its exaggeration and self-conscious theatricality as a critique of political mythology, ideological manipulation, and the impossibility of reducing a complex history to one authoritative narrative.
These interpretations cannot be collapsed into a single answer without losing something important.
The film's satire of Tito-era political mythmaking does not establish that all parties in the Yugoslav wars bear identical historical responsibility.
And its criticism of nationalism does not make it a neutral documentary account of how those wars began.
It remains a fictional, politically charged representation.
A work that can reveal mechanisms of power while also inviting serious criticism of its own choices.
We should therefore resist using the film to claim that the conflicts were simply the inevitable consequence of people who naturally love war, drinking, and noise.
That would turn a particular, historically situated catastrophe into a stereotype.
And it would repeat the very problem the film makes so difficult to ignore.
A compelling story can become more persuasive than a careful account of what happened.
The Charismatic Liar Is Still a Liar
Marko is one of the film's most important figures because he makes deception socially attractive.
He is energetic.
Resourceful.
Connected.
Capable of moving between worlds.
He understands politics, performance, opportunity, and the usefulness of being seen as a hero.
He is not simply a faceless bureaucrat issuing orders from an anonymous office.
He belongs to the same world of excess as Blacky.
He participates in its drinking, passions, friendships, and theatrical masculinity.
His charisma helps make his manipulation plausible.
The people below have reasons to trust him.
They share a history.
He appears to represent their interests.
He supplies information and resources.
He maintains the story of resistance.
But the personal relationship does not eliminate the asymmetry.
Marko can leave.
They cannot.
Marko knows the war has ended.
They do not.
Marko accumulates wealth and status.
They continue working underground.
The more entertaining and emotionally compelling he becomes, the more important it is to remember the structure he maintains.
A charming person can exploit others.
A generous gesture can coexist with systematic dishonesty.
And a leader can sincerely enjoy the community whose freedom he restricts.
In fact, shared affection may make manipulation easier.
People are not always controlled by being made miserable.
Sometimes they are controlled through relationships and identities they genuinely value.
The lie does not have to eliminate pleasure.
It can organize pleasure into something that helps preserve the lie.
The Music Doesn't Tell Us What Is True
Music has an extraordinary capacity to alter the emotional significance of a scene.
A rhythm can make movement feel purposeful.
A melody can produce tenderness.
A brass band can turn an ordinary gathering into an event.
And the same sounds may accompany grief, triumph, danger, or absurdity.
In Underground, the music frequently refuses to tell us whether we should be celebrating or mourning.
The musicians play.
The camera moves.
Bodies dance.
People shout and embrace.
Sometimes the energy is delightful.
Sometimes it becomes almost unbearable.
The viewer is invited into an experience that is simultaneously attractive and alarming.
And this is where the film becomes especially interesting psychologically.
Emotional intensity can feel like evidence of significance.
A moment is overwhelming.
Therefore, it must matter.
Everyone feels connected.
Therefore, the group must be moving in the right direction.
The music is extraordinary.
Therefore, the event must possess some kind of truth.
But these conclusions do not follow automatically.
Collective emotion is real.
Its interpretation remains open.
People can experience powerful solidarity around a just cause.
They can also experience solidarity around a false belief.
Music can support mourning.
It can accompany propaganda.
It can create genuine connection.
And it can help a crowd avoid attending to something it would rather not recognize.
The emotional experience does not determine the moral quality of the situation.
One can be deeply moved and badly mistaken at the same time.
When Feeling Alive Becomes a Way of Avoiding Life
There is a familiar psychological distinction between moving toward an experience and moving away from another one.
A person may attend a party because they enjoy their friends.
Because they love music.
Because celebration matters to them.
Or because they want to participate in a shared occasion.
These are ordinary, potentially valuable reasons.
But the same behavior can also be used to avoid something uncomfortable.
A difficult conversation.
A painful memory.
Loneliness.
An unresolved conflict.
The prospect of returning to an empty room.
Psychologists use the term experiential avoidance for patterns in which people attempt to escape or suppress unwanted internal experiences in ways that can become costly over time.
The concept does not mean that distraction is always unhealthy.
Taking a break from distress can be useful.
Nor does it imply that dancing, drinking, or enjoying a celebration is evidence of a psychological problem.
The question concerns flexibility.
Can the person stop?
Can they recognize when the activity is no longer serving them?
Can they return to an uncomfortable reality when doing so becomes necessary?
Or has the activity become the only available way to avoid confronting something?
In Kusturica's world, the celebrations sometimes seem incapable of ending.
People continue performing vitality through grief, conflict, betrayal, and catastrophe.
The energy is intoxicating.
But it can also feel compulsory.
As though silence would expose something that the participants are not prepared to hear.
The problem is not the music.
It is the possibility that the music has become necessary to prevent another experience from entering awareness.
The party is no longer simply an expression of joy.
It may also be a defense against the absence of joy.
The Silence Nobody Knows What to Do With
Imagine the cellar without music.
No celebration.
No shouting.
No wedding.
No ritual affirming that everyone remains united in the same struggle.
Just an ordinary evening.
People sitting together.
The work interrupted.
Nothing particularly exciting happening.
What questions might become possible?
How long have we been here?
Why has the war continued for so many years?
Why do we never receive reliable news from anywhere else?
What kind of life might exist above us?
Why must everything we know pass through Marko?
And what exactly are we waiting for?
Of course, the film's inhabitants are not entirely free to investigate these questions.
Their access to the outside world has been deliberately restricted.
Their predicament is not explained by an inability to sit quietly with their thoughts.
But the imagined silence reveals something about the role of collective performance.
Rituals can help a community preserve solidarity.
They can also make a particular interpretation of reality feel so natural that questioning it becomes socially difficult.
The music reinforces a shared emotional world.
The wedding confirms continuity.
The work confirms duty.
The story confirms purpose.
And the repetition creates an impression that the world has remained coherent.
Stopping would not automatically reveal the truth.
But it might create space in which the familiar story no longer fills every available moment.
There is something unsettling about a celebration that cannot tolerate a pause.
Joy normally permits rest.
Compulsion does not.
Is Intensity the Same Thing as Presence?
This brings us to the Zen-inspired question.
Kusturica's films are often described as exuberant celebrations of life.
And it is tempting to equate their intensity with a kind of radical presence.
The characters are bodily.
Emotional.
Spontaneous.
They seem incapable of living halfway.
When they love, they love dramatically.
When they suffer, they suffer extravagantly.
When they celebrate, the entire world appears to join the celebration.
Surely these people are more alive than the controlled, cautious individuals who spend their days managing calendars and worrying about tomorrow.
Perhaps.
But intensity and presence are not the same thing.
A person can be completely absorbed in an experience without recognizing important aspects of what is happening.
A crowd can experience emotional unity while misunderstanding the event that brought it together.
Someone can feel wonderfully alive while engaging in behavior that repeatedly damages their relationships.
Strong emotion does not guarantee clear attention.
And an absence of restraint does not establish psychological freedom.
This is where the comparison with Zen becomes useful.
Zen Buddhist practice does not require an absence of emotion, music, pleasure, or celebration.
Nor does it suggest that a quiet life is automatically superior to a vivid one.
But it places importance on the capacity to encounter experience without being completely governed by habitual reactions and rigid attachments.
The central distinction is not between loud and quiet.
It is between responsiveness and compulsion.
Can I dance because dancing is appropriate to this moment?
Can I stop when the moment changes?
Can I enjoy the music without needing it to protect me from every unpleasant thought?
Can I participate fully in a celebration while remaining able to notice the person who is suffering beside me?
Perhaps genuine presence is less about how intensely we experience something and more about whether we can remain responsive to what is actually there.
Acceptance Is Not the Same Thing as Having Another Drink
There is a popular misunderstanding of acceptance.
Life is chaotic.
Human beings are imperfect.
History is painful.
Therefore, we should embrace everything.
Celebrate.
Drink.
Dance.
Refuse to become too serious.
Let life happen.
There is something attractive about this philosophy.
It can serve as a necessary correction to the fantasy that a worthwhile life must be perfectly ordered and controlled.
But acceptance does not mean refusing to distinguish between what is happening and what we would prefer to believe.
And it does not mean abandoning moral responsibility.
A person can accept that life contains uncertainty while still investigating a lie.
Recognize that suffering is part of existence while still trying to prevent unnecessary harm.
Enjoy a celebration while acknowledging the political circumstances surrounding it.
Or mourn a destroyed country without inventing a history in which nobody bears responsibility for its destruction.
The ability to live amid complexity is not the same thing as the decision to stop examining complexity.
In fact, acceptance may sometimes require more difficult attention.
We may have to recognize that the people we love have deceived us.
That a group to which we belong has participated in harm.
That the story sustaining our identity is incomplete.
Or that our most cherished memories are connected with events we can no longer interpret innocently.
These recognitions are painful.
But avoiding them does not necessarily make life more accepting.
It may make our relationship with life narrower.
The celebration becomes a protected space.
And the rest of reality must remain outside.
In Underground, that metaphor has become literal.
The Country That Lives Through Its Stories
The film's historical dimensions become especially important when we consider the idea of Yugoslavia itself.
A country is not merely a geographical territory.
It is also a political and social reality sustained through institutions, relationships, laws, memories, and stories of belonging.
People can genuinely love a country.
Associate it with family histories.
Languages.
Music.
Cities.
Friendships.
Childhood.
Shared experiences that cannot be neatly separated according to later political boundaries.
The collapse of such a country can therefore be experienced as more than an administrative change.
It can alter a person's understanding of where they belong and how their past connects with their future.
Underground is saturated with this loss.
But the film also exposes how national stories can become instruments of power.
A heroic narrative may preserve real acts of courage.
It may also conceal exploitation.
A collective memory may sustain belonging.
It may also suppress contradictions.
Nostalgia can contain authentic grief.
It can also simplify the past.
The challenge is not to declare every collective memory false.
That would be as reductive as treating every beloved national story as historically complete.
The challenge is to distinguish the value of belonging from the authority claimed by those who control its representation.
Marko's deception depends on precisely this confusion.
He borrows the language of loyalty and sacrifice.
Turns it into a reason for obedience.
And profits from the people who believe that obedience remains necessary.
The emotional attachments are genuine.
The political arrangement is exploitative.
Both truths matter.
The Film That Became Its Own Political Argument
There is an additional complication.
The viewer is not standing outside all these mechanisms.
We are watching a film that constructs its own extraordinarily persuasive world.
Kusturica uses music, movement, grotesque comedy, historical references, and melodrama to make that world emotionally compelling.
The film itself creates a powerful narrative about a vanished country.
It invites us to mourn.
Laugh.
Feel affection.
Become nostalgic.
And experience the destruction of Yugoslavia through images whose political implications are contested.
This is one reason the debates surrounding Underground cannot be dismissed as a misunderstanding by people who failed to appreciate artistic complexity.
Some criticism concerns the effects of the film's form itself.
Does its excess expose the dangerous relationship between collective fantasy and political violence?
Or can the same excess make violence appear timeless, inevitable, or culturally characteristic?
Does its nostalgia preserve the memory of a shared world?
Or does it obscure inequalities and historical responsibilities that cannot be repaired by imagining the country as a lost family gathering?
Different scholars and critics have offered conflicting answers.
And the film may support more than one reading.
Its political meaning cannot be settled simply by pointing to the fact that Marko is a liar.
Nor by claiming that every scene should be understood ironically.
The emotional pleasure of a work can be part of its political significance.
The music that makes a scene irresistible may also make the story surrounding that scene easier to accept.
The viewer is therefore confronted with the same problem as the inhabitants of the film.
How do we remain open to the emotional power of a shared story without surrendering our responsibility to examine what it leaves out?
The Wedding After Everything Has Ended
Then comes the final wedding.
The film has moved through war, betrayal, death, and the destruction of a political world.
People who have fought, deceived, lost, and suffered return in a dreamlike reunion.
The sunlight is warm.
The table is full.
The music plays.
The dead and living seem temporarily reconciled.
Jovan's wedding, previously celebrated in the darkness of the cellar, becomes a luminous gathering beside the river.
For a moment, the film offers something that ordinary history cannot.
The possibility of everyone coming home.
The possibility of forgiveness.
The possibility that the people who were separated by violence and betrayal might sit together again.
This is an extraordinarily moving image.
It is also impossible to read simply.
Is it a vision of reconciliation?
A memory of a country that no longer exists?
A dream in which history's losses can finally be reversed?
Or the final transformation of collective self-deception into a beautiful image?
Perhaps all of these possibilities remain available.
The emotional force of the scene does not depend on choosing only one.
But Kusturica adds a final detail that prevents the celebration from becoming entirely reassuring.
The land beneath the wedding begins separating from the shore.
The guests continue eating, singing, and dancing.
And the little piece of land drifts away.
The Island That Nobody Notices Leaving
This is the image I would keep returning to.
The wedding guests are together.
They appear happy.
Their conflicts seem, at least temporarily, resolved.
The celebration possesses everything the characters have sought throughout the film.
Music.
Family.
Love.
Belonging.
An end to conflict.
And yet the ground itself is moving.
The gathering has become detached from the larger world.
The participants do not appear to notice.
Dina Iordanova has interpreted this ending as both an idealized wedding and a warning about drifting away in oblivious celebration.
Other critics have emphasized the image's utopian possibilities, its nostalgic reconstruction of a shared Yugoslav space, or the contradiction between its beauty and the historical violence preceding it.
The ambiguity is essential.
The floating island can appear liberating.
A small world escaping the destruction around it.
A place where people can remain together after history has made their togetherness impossible.
But it can also appear terrifying.
The ultimate closed community.
A beautiful celebration that continues while losing contact with the shore.
The guests possess a shared emotional experience.
They no longer have a secure relation to the world beyond it.
This is not simply a metaphor for personal denial.
It is a vision of what happens when belonging becomes detached from history.
The community survives as an image.
But its relation to political and historical reality has become impossible to stabilize.
The music continues.
The land drifts.
And nobody interrupts the party to ask where they are going.
Can You Celebrate Without Looking Away?
Perhaps the deepest question raised by Underground is not whether celebration is good or bad.
It is whether celebration can coexist with an honest awareness of the circumstances in which it takes place.
A person can dance at a wedding while grieving someone who is absent.
A community can sing after a catastrophe without pretending that the catastrophe did not happen.
People can cherish memories of a lost country while acknowledging that its history included conflict, exploitation, and injustice.
Joy does not need to be innocent of suffering.
Indeed, some forms of joy become more meaningful precisely because the people experiencing them know how fragile life is.
But such celebration requires room for other responses.
Grief.
Anger.
Disagreement.
Silence.
Questions.
The possibility of stopping.
A celebration becomes restrictive when these responses threaten the unity it is supposed to maintain.
When the person who refuses to dance is treated as disloyal.
When questioning the official story spoils the mood.
When the group needs everyone to remain enthusiastic because the alternative is confronting what the celebration conceals.
Then the party is no longer simply a place of shared freedom.
It has become another institution enforcing a particular emotional reality.
The question is not whether everyone should become more restrained.
It is whether they are allowed to be otherwise.
Can the music stop without the community falling apart?
Can the story be questioned without belonging becoming impossible?
Can people recognize what happened without abandoning every source of joy that helped them survive it?
These possibilities would distinguish a living community from one that must continually perform its own vitality.
The Last Song
Kusturica's film does not offer a comfortable answer.
Its excessive style resists the idea that truth must be quiet and joy must be restrained.
It knows that people sometimes survive unbearable circumstances through music, laughter, love, and the absurd persistence of ordinary pleasures.
Those experiences should not be dismissed.
They are part of life.
But the film also shows how the same energy can participate in maintaining an oppressive illusion.
How loyalty can be exploited.
How a charismatic liar can turn a collective story into an instrument of power.
And how a community can become deeply united around an account of reality it has been prevented from examining.
The tragedy is not that the people in the cellar celebrate.
It is that someone has made their world so narrow that celebration and obedience exist inside the same manufactured reality.
And the final image returns us to that contradiction without resolving it.
A wedding.
A table.
Music.
A country that no longer exists.
People embracing one another as the land beneath them drifts away.
We can interpret the scene as a beautiful refusal to let historical catastrophe destroy the possibility of human connection.
We can also see it as the ultimate expression of a fantasy so complete that its inhabitants no longer recognize their separation from reality.
Perhaps the power of the image lies in its refusal to let us choose comfortably.
The celebration is moving.
The detachment is frightening.
The loss is real.
The reconciliation may be imaginary.
And the music remains magnificent.
A Zen-inspired comparison does not require us to condemn the party or praise silence as inherently wiser.
It asks something more difficult.
Can we experience joy without needing joy to exclude everything else?
Can we remain present to love and music while also recognizing fear, grief, exploitation, and historical responsibility?
Can we belong to a community without allowing its shared emotional life to determine what we are permitted to know?
And can we stop dancing when the ground beneath our feet has begun to move?
Perhaps accepting life means being capable of both celebration and silence.
Not because one is morally superior to the other.
But because reality contains experiences that require different responses.
Sometimes the music is exactly what we need.
Sometimes someone has to turn it down and ask what happened.
And sometimes the most important person in the room is the one who notices that the party is floating away.
We do not become more present simply by feeling life more intensely.
We become more present when we can bear to notice what is happening, even when noticing it interrupts the music.
Sources
Festival de Cannes: Underground (1995)
Dina Iordanova, Balkan Wedding Revisited (1998)
Dina Iordanova, Kusturica's Underground: Historical Allegory or Propaganda?
Igor Krstic, Representing Yugoslavia?
Andrei Poamă, Propaganda, Power and Darkness in Underground
Ana Đorđević, Unresolved Trauma and Balkan Stereotypes in the Music of Underground
Páez et al., Psychosocial Effects of Perceived Emotional Synchrony in Collective Gatherings
Acceptance and Commitment Therapy: A Transdiagnostic Behavioral Intervention
Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy: Japanese Zen Buddhist Philosophy

Illustration supplied from the owner-authorized image reserve.
