
Cover image supplied from the owner-authorized Psychology Notebook reserve.
Liminality, unfinished transitions, and the psychological cost of living between what was and what comes next.
One of the easiest ways to lose several years of your life is to convince yourself that you're currently in a transition.
Nothing permanent.
Just a temporary situation.
You're between relationships. Between careers. Between versions of yourself. Between the life you used to have and the life you're definitely going to start living once a few things have been sorted out.
You aren't staying.
You're passing through.
Except that you've been passing through for seven years.
The temporary relationship has become your primary relationship. The provisional job has become your career. The apartment you rented until you figured things out is now furnished with objects you bought to make the waiting more comfortable.
You are still preparing for the next chapter.
And the preparation has quietly become the chapter.
There is a psychological difference between being in transition and being trapped in a transitional state.
The first allows something to change.
The second can become an extraordinarily sophisticated way of preventing change.
The doorway was supposed to lead somewhere. It was never meant to become your home.
A Transition Is More Than an Interval
In 1909, the anthropologist Arnold van Gennep published The Rites of Passage, a study of how societies organize important changes in human life.
Birth.
Puberty.
Marriage.
Changes of social status.
Death.
He recognized a recurring structure in the rituals surrounding such transformations.
First, separation from an existing condition.
Then a transitional period.
Finally, incorporation into a new social position.
The transition is not simply an empty interval between two stable states.
It is a distinctive phase in which the old identity has been loosened while the new one has not yet been fully established.
The anthropologist Victor Turner later developed this idea through the concept of liminality.
The word derives from the Latin limen, meaning threshold.
The liminal person stands between recognized positions.
No longer entirely what they were.
Not yet what they are becoming.
The ordinary rules of identity and belonging may temporarily lose their authority.
This is an ambiguous condition, and ambiguity can be productive.
The old arrangement is suspended.
Other possibilities become imaginable.
There is room for transformation.
But in traditional rites of passage, the threshold belongs to a larger process.
The ritual makes the change recognizable.
It creates a framework.
It helps distinguish what has ended, what is taking place, and what new condition is being entered.
The important feature is not that every transition has a precise deadline.
Many real transitions are unpredictable and cannot be scheduled.
It is that the transitional phase is understood as part of a movement rather than an indefinite substitute for arriving somewhere.
The threshold has a purpose.
You cross it.
The Strange Exhaustion of Being Almost Somewhere
Modern life is remarkably good at producing transitions without recognizable endings.
A relationship is over, but not officially over.
Someone has left home but remains psychologically dependent on the family.
A career has become intolerable, but the person continues preparing for the day they will finally change it.
A divorce is legally complete, but the former partners remain locked in a relationship organized around resentment, surveillance, and unfinished arguments.
The old structure has lost its credibility.
The new one has not acquired enough reality to replace it.
So the person remains suspended.
This can consume an extraordinary amount of psychological energy.
Decisions are continually rehearsed but never completed.
Expectations remain provisional.
Commitments are postponed.
The person cannot fully invest in the present because the present is supposedly temporary.
Nor can they invest in the future because they have not yet accepted what must be left behind.
Life becomes an enormous waiting room.
And unlike an ordinary waiting room, nobody announces when the next appointment begins.
Social theorist Árpád Szakolczai has written about permanent liminality: situations in which the suspension of ordinary structures, initially imagined as temporary, becomes persistent.
The idea is paradoxical.
A transition is supposed to involve movement.
How can one remain permanently in transit?
Psychologically, the paradox is quite recognizable.
The person continues to describe themselves as becoming something else.
But the becoming no longer produces change.
It has become a stable way of not being fully committed to anything.
The Hidden Cost of Crossing a Threshold
Why would someone remain in this condition?
Sometimes because circumstances leave them little choice.
War, displacement, illness, poverty, legal uncertainty, and unstable work can force people into prolonged transitions whose endings they cannot control.
A person waiting for asylum is not necessarily avoiding psychological development.
Someone caring for a terminally ill relative cannot simply decide that the transition should now be complete.
Structural uncertainty must not be confused with an unconscious refusal to change.
But when external possibilities are available and the person remains persistently unable to make use of them, another question becomes relevant.
What would completing the transition require them to lose?
There is a problem with becoming somebody new.
You cannot remain every previous version of yourself.
Choosing one career means abandoning some imagined alternatives.
Ending a relationship means relinquishing not only the actual partner but also the future you had hoped might exist with them.
Becoming independent of your parents means giving up the fantasy that you can remain their child in precisely the old way.
Accepting age means recognizing that certain possibilities belong to the past.
Every transition contains some combination of gain and loss.
And the loss is not always dramatic.
Sometimes it is the death of a fantasy.
The fantasy that everything can still work out exactly as originally imagined.
That nobody has to be disappointed.
That the old relationship can somehow become the ideal relationship.
That a different choice will eventually allow all the other choices to remain available.
The threshold makes this fantasy temporarily possible.
While you stand between two worlds, you can imagine that both still belong to you.
Crossing means discovering that they do not.
Borderline Organization: The Transition Without a Ritual
Here is where an anthropological idea becomes a provocative psychoanalytic metaphor.
Imagine a psychological organization in which the person struggles to integrate conflicting experiences of themselves and others.
The loved person becomes the hated person.
The idealized relationship becomes the intolerable relationship.
The self that felt confident yesterday becomes the self that feels worthless today.
Otto Kernberg described borderline personality organization in terms of identity diffusion, primitive defenses such as splitting, and generally preserved reality testing.
This is a level of personality organization in his psychodynamic model, not simply another name for borderline personality disorder.
And it is not clinically defined by an inability to complete transitions.
Nevertheless, there is a revealing analogy between certain borderline dynamics and a passage that never reaches its final stage.
The person may struggle to accept a sufficiently integrated reality.
A partner can be loving and disappointing.
A parent can have provided something valuable and failed terribly in other ways.
A relationship can have been meaningful and still need to end.
A decision can be necessary without being perfect.
Splitting offers a temporary escape from these contradictions.
The loved person can remain completely good until disappointment becomes unbearable.
Then they become completely bad.
The relationship is over.
Then it is the only relationship worth saving.
The person wants to leave.
Then cannot tolerate being left.
The emotional experience repeatedly changes without becoming integrated into a durable understanding of the relationship.
In the language of our metaphor, the person approaches the threshold but struggles to complete the passage.
Not because people with borderline organization are incapable of change. Effective psychotherapy can help improve identity integration, emotional regulation, and relational functioning.
And not because an ordinary ceremony would cure a personality disorder.
The missing ritual here is conceptual.
It represents the psychological capacity to acknowledge an ending and integrate its consequences.
To say:
This relationship mattered.
It was imperfect.
It cannot become everything I wanted.
And I must now decide what its reality means for my life.
Such recognition requires giving up something painful.
The possibility that the real object might still transform into the ideal one without anything being lost.
As long as the person remains between idealization and devaluation, between union and rupture, the finality of that loss can be postponed.
The passage remains unfinished.
And the unfinished passage can become a familiar way of relating.
The Seduction of Having Both Worlds
There is an emotional advantage to never quite crossing.
Before a decision is final, competing possibilities can remain alive in imagination.
The relationship can be simultaneously unbearable and potentially perfect.
A career can be both rejected and not yet abandoned.
The old identity can be disowned without being relinquished.
The new identity can be desired without being inhabited.
The person keeps the psychological benefits of both sides while avoiding some of the costs of choosing.
But those benefits become less impressive over time.
A relationship that is always about to change may never develop.
A life that is always about to begin may become increasingly empty.
And an identity that remains perpetually provisional may offer little continuity when the person needs to know who they are.
The original uncertainty was understandable.
The permanent suspension becomes expensive.
It is possible to remain in a state of almost making a decision until the world eventually makes the decision for you.
The partner leaves.
The opportunity disappears.
The job ends.
The body ages.
Time, unfortunately, does not agree to remain provisional simply because we do.
The Opposite Arrangement: A Ritual That Prevents Passage
Now consider a different possibility.
What if the person is not avoiding ritual?
What if their life is full of rituals?
Elaborate routines.
Repetitive dramatic scenarios.
Strict rules.
Symbolic gestures.
Recurring conflicts that follow an almost ceremonial sequence.
Every detail has its place.
Every participant knows the role they are expected to play.
Something intense happens.
It concludes.
And then everything returns to precisely the same position.
The ritual is completed.
The transition is not.
This offers the second half of our analogy.
If one defensive arrangement resembles a transition without a completing ritual, another resembles a ritual designed to prevent the transition from occurring.
Certain psychoanalytic theories of perverse organizations describe patterns in which repetition, control, and the disavowal of psychological reality can become central.
The terminology requires care.
In contemporary clinical language, consensual unconventional sexuality is not, by itself, a mental disorder. A paraphilia is not automatically a paraphilic disorder, and the older psychoanalytic term perversion has often been used far more broadly and judgmentally than modern evidence warrants.
The meaning intended here is narrower and theoretical.
It concerns a defensive organization in which an enactment can replace the emotional transformation it appears to promise.
A person repeatedly stages the same psychological conflict.
They return to the same humiliation.
The same reversal of power.
The same betrayal, punishment, reconciliation, or triumph.
The event produces intensity.
Perhaps even relief.
But the underlying relationship to loss, dependence, or reality remains unchanged.
The ritual does not carry the person across a threshold.
It maintains the threshold as a permanent theatre.
When the Symbol Becomes More Important Than What It Means
There is a useful religious image for this distinction.
In the Christian narrative, the crucifixion is not simply an isolated spectacle of suffering.
It belongs to the larger movement through death toward resurrection.
The cross carries meaning within a story of transformation.
Now imagine the symbolic structure reversed.
Instead of pointing beyond suffering, the image of suffering becomes the entire destination.
The ritual is repeated not so that anything can change, but to preserve the moment that prevents change.
The cross, in this metaphor, ceases to function as a sign of passage.
It becomes an object around which the passage is suspended.
This is not a claim about Christian worship, nor a psychological interpretation of religious devotion.
It is an illustration of a more general possibility.
Symbols can help us acknowledge a transformation.
But symbols can also be used to preserve the fantasy that transformation has already taken place when nothing essential has changed.
A person repeatedly declares that they are beginning a new life.
But the declaration itself becomes the substitute for beginning.
A couple repeatedly stages the same dramatic breakup and reconciliation.
But the ritual of reunion substitutes for the development of intimacy.
Someone returns again and again to a scene of humiliation, victory, or symbolic revenge.
But the emotional event replaces the need to recognize an irreversible loss.
The repetition becomes compelling precisely because it promises something it does not deliver.
There is always another performance.
Another cycle.
Another opportunity to complete what remains incomplete.
And so the person never quite leaves the stage.
The Ritual Is Working. That Is the Problem.
It would be easy to describe repetitive rituals as failures.
But many are successful at their immediate psychological task.
They reduce uncertainty.
Establish familiar roles.
Organize emotional intensity.
Create a temporary sense of mastery.
Protect against an encounter with grief, dependence, or helplessness.
The problem is that the immediate psychological task may be incompatible with longer-term change.
Consider a relationship that repeatedly collapses into the same conflict.
One person withdraws.
The other pursues.
The withdrawing partner becomes contemptuous.
The pursuing partner becomes desperate.
Eventually there is a dramatic reunion.
Passion returns.
Both experience relief.
For a few days, the relationship feels transformed.
Then the cycle begins again.
It would be simplistic to classify every such relationship as a perverse organization. Attachment dynamics, trauma, coercion, interpersonal incompatibility, and many other processes can contribute to repetitive patterns.
But the structure reveals something worth examining.
The crisis and reconciliation may temporarily substitute for the difficult work of developing a different relationship.
There is intensity without sustained transformation.
Movement without passage.
The ritual produces an ending to the episode, but not an ending to the pattern.
It does exactly what it has been organized to do.
It brings everyone back to the beginning.
Two Ways to Refuse an Ending
The contrast becomes clearer when we place the two metaphors beside each other.
In the first arrangement, an ending is repeatedly postponed.
There is no sufficient integration of what has happened.
The old and new positions remain difficult to distinguish.
The person cannot fully enter one reality because doing so would require relinquishing the ideal possibilities of the other.
In the second arrangement, endings are repeatedly performed.
There are ceremonies of separation, destruction, punishment, reconciliation, and rebirth.
But their repetition protects against a more fundamental ending.
The person never has to confront the fact that the original object, relationship, or fantasy cannot be restored.
Both arrangements can defend against mourning.
And both can protect against the recognition that time is irreversible.
One says:
Not yet. I haven't really chosen.
The other says:
Again. This time the ritual will finally work.
The first keeps the decision open.
The second repeats an enactment that makes deciding unnecessary.
Both can create the subjective impression of psychological activity while preserving a remarkable degree of psychological immobility.
It is important not to turn this contrast into a diagnostic law.
Borderline personality organization and psychoanalytic perverse organizations are not established as two exhaustive types of failed transition.
They overlap in some theoretical traditions and cannot be differentiated merely by observing whether a person performs rituals.
What the contrast offers is a way of thinking about two defensive relationships to change.
One preserves possibility by withholding completion.
The other preserves repetition by withholding transformation.
The Unfinished Transition Is Also an Unmourned Loss
Underneath both arrangements lies the same difficulty.
Something must be acknowledged as finished.
The child who imagined the perfect parent must confront the parent's limitations.
The adult who hoped for an ideal relationship must recognize the actual relationship.
The person who expected unlimited time must accept that certain possibilities have passed.
The self that existed before an illness, a divorce, a death, or a betrayal may not be recoverable in its previous form.
Transitions bring us into contact with reality.
And reality is often disappointing.
It refuses to preserve every possibility.
It does not guarantee that the new condition will compensate for everything lost in the old one.
A different life is not necessarily a better life in every respect.
It may simply be the life that has become possible.
To cross the threshold can therefore involve grief.
Not only grief for people.
Grief for roles.
For futures that never happened.
For versions of ourselves that can no longer exist.
For the fantasy that somewhere, if we just wait or repeat the correct ritual, life will finally become what it should always have been.
The transition cannot be completed without some capacity to tolerate this loss.
And sometimes the most important thing a ritual can accomplish is not to create a new reality.
It is to make an already existing reality emotionally recognizable.
Why Rituals Matter
A genuine rite of passage does not abolish uncertainty.
Nor does it magically eliminate grief.
But it can provide a structure for recognizing change.
Something has ended.
Something remains unresolved.
Something new is beginning.
In many traditional societies, this structure was supported by a community.
The transformation was not only an internal psychological event.
Other people witnessed it.
A new status was recognized.
A change that might otherwise have remained ambiguous acquired a social reality.
Modern life has plenty of administrative transitions but fewer shared ways of marking their psychological meaning.
A divorce can be legally finalized while remaining emotionally unfinished.
A person can leave a profession without knowing who they are outside it.
A death can be formally registered while its implications for the survivor's identity remain difficult to grasp.
The rituals available to us may not be sufficient.
Sometimes we have to create our own ways of recognizing an ending.
A conversation.
A farewell.
A decision made publicly or privately.
A change in routine.
The acceptance of a new responsibility.
An act that establishes a boundary between what is no longer possible and what must now be lived.
But there is an important difference between using a ritual to acknowledge change and expecting ritual to produce change automatically.
A symbolic gesture cannot substitute for the necessary emotional or practical work.
Throwing away a former partner's photographs does not guarantee that the relationship has been mourned.
Signing a resignation letter does not instantly create a new identity.
And declaring a fresh start every Monday does not necessarily mean that Tuesday will be any different.
The ritual matters when it is connected to a real transition.
Without that connection, it can become another decorative threshold.
The Moment When Waiting Becomes Avoidance
How do we recognize that a transition has become a trap?
Duration alone is not enough.
Some changes genuinely take years.
Grief, recovery, retraining, family transitions, and rebuilding after trauma cannot always be hurried without making things worse.
The more useful question concerns direction.
Is the uncertainty slowly becoming more understandable?
Are new choices becoming possible?
Is the person gradually developing a different relationship to what has been lost?
Or does every apparent advance reproduce exactly the same position?
Another promising relationship.
Another identical collapse.
Another elaborate explanation.
Another declaration that the real beginning is just around the corner.
And another year spent preparing.
There may be good reasons for delay.
Fear, lack of resources, ongoing danger, social obligations, or unfinished practical tasks.
But there may also be a psychological investment in remaining between possibilities.
Because as long as the new life has not begun, it cannot disappoint you.
As long as the relationship has not truly ended, its imagined ideal version remains available.
As long as you have not made the decision, you can continue imagining the person you would have become if you had chosen differently.
The unfinished transition protects possibility.
And sometimes destroys the conditions under which possibility could become reality.
You Don't Cross by Becoming Ready Forever
There is a familiar fantasy about difficult life transitions.
One day, everything will become clear.
You will understand yourself completely.
The fear will disappear.
The past will finally make sense.
All the relevant people will agree.
You will feel ready.
Then you will cross.
Occasionally, life is kind enough to provide something resembling this arrangement.
More often, important transitions involve acting without complete certainty.
The decision is made before the emotional consequences are fully understood.
A relationship ends before every question has been answered.
An identity changes before the person feels entirely comfortable inhabiting it.
Grief continues after life has already begun moving forward.
Crossing a threshold does not require becoming perfectly free of ambivalence.
It requires enough integration and support to recognize which reality one is entering.
And enough willingness to accept that the alternative cannot remain indefinitely preserved in exactly the form one imagined.
This is not an argument for impulsive decisions, forced closure, or pushing people out of necessary periods of transition.
Some thresholds cannot safely be crossed without material preparation.
Others are crossed gradually.
And some losses never receive a neat ceremonial ending.
The point is that psychological passage involves more than time passing or a ritual being repeated.
Something in the person's relationship with reality must change.
The Door That Has Been Open All Along
There is something particularly sad about a life suspended between two forms.
The person has already lost much of the old world.
But has not permitted themselves to enter the new one.
They remain loyal to possibilities that no longer exist.
Or repeat rituals that promise transformation while carefully preventing it.
Sometimes the situation looks dramatic.
An endless cycle of crisis and reconciliation.
A life organized around revenge.
A desperate refusal to accept an ending.
Sometimes it looks perfectly ordinary.
A job you will leave next year.
A decision you will make when you feel ready.
A life that will begin once one last condition has been satisfied.
And suddenly a decade has passed.
The anthropological image of the threshold is useful precisely because it reminds us that the in-between has a purpose.
It provides space for transformation.
But transformation requires more than remaining suspended.
Something must be relinquished.
Something must be recognized.
Something must be allowed to become real.
The old form does not have to be hated.
The new form does not have to be ideal.
And the passage does not have to erase everything that came before.
But at some point, if circumstances permit, life asks us to stop treating the interval as a permanent exemption from choosing.
The ritual is meant to mark a change.
Not to replace it.
The threshold is meant to be crossed.
Not endlessly decorated.
And perhaps one of the most important psychological questions is not whether we're ready for the next chapter, but what we're protecting by insisting that the previous one hasn't quite ended.
Reading note
This essay expands on the earlier reflection A Threshold Is Not a Home. The anthropological and psychoanalytic comparisons are interpretive, not clinical definitions; prolonged transitions can also reflect circumstances outside a person’s control.
