A stylized face surrounded by fractured red and blue shapes.

Cover image supplied from the owner-authorized Psychology Notebook reserve.

Spoiler warning: This essay discusses major events in the Star Wars prequel and original trilogies.

Anakin, Luke, the psychology of attachment, and the difference between saving someone and trying to own their fate.

There is a particularly dangerous sentence that people sometimes say when they are frightened of losing someone.

I would do anything to save you.

It sounds romantic.

Devoted.

Almost heroic.

And under ordinary circumstances, it may simply mean that someone is prepared to make considerable sacrifices for a person they love.

But what exactly does anything include?

Lying?

Betraying friends?

Destroying relationships?

Taking away the other person's freedom?

Hurting innocent people?

What if the person you are trying to save no longer wants the kind of salvation you have arranged for them?

And what if the fear of losing someone becomes so overwhelming that the person you supposedly love disappears behind your determination to keep them?

George Lucas built one of cinema's most famous tragedies around precisely this problem.

Anakin Skywalker loves Padmé Amidala.

He is terrified that she will die.

He becomes convinced that obtaining enough power will allow him to prevent her death.

And in trying to save her, he becomes the very person she can no longer recognize.

Years later, his son Luke faces another seemingly impossible relationship.

He believes there is still goodness in Darth Vader.

He wants to save his father.

But at the decisive moment, Luke does something Anakin could not.

He refuses to make the desired outcome more important than the kind of person he chooses to be.

The difference between them is not that one loves and the other does not.

Both love.

Both are afraid.

Both face the possibility of losing someone important.

The difference concerns what they are willing to do with that fear.

Anakin tries to gain enough power that loss will become impossible. Luke acts out of love without obtaining a guarantee that love will succeed.

And somewhere between these two choices lies a much more interesting understanding of attachment than the familiar instruction to simply let go.

The Boy Who Learned That Love Can Disappear

Anakin's tragedy does not begin with Padmé.

It begins long before their marriage, on Tatooine.

He is a child living in slavery.

His mother, Shmi, is the center of his emotional world.

When Qui-Gon Jinn offers him the possibility of leaving and training as a Jedi, Anakin faces a choice no child should have to make lightly.

He can move toward freedom.

But he must leave his mother behind.

His new life begins with a separation from the person who has provided his most important source of security.

The Jedi recognize his extraordinary potential.

They also recognize his fear.

And from the beginning, Anakin's attachment becomes a concern within the Order.

This is an important detail because it complicates the simple story of a selfish man who wants to possess people.

Anakin begins as a frightened child who has already experienced circumstances in which people can be taken away, controlled, and separated from one another.

His fear has a history.

Later, when he returns to Tatooine in Attack of the Clones, he discovers his mother dying after captivity and abuse.

He responds with grief and a massacre.

That violence is his responsibility.

The experience of loss does not excuse killing innocent people.

But it establishes a pattern that will become central to his later tragedy.

He experiences helplessness.

Someone he loves suffers.

He responds by trying to transform helplessness into overwhelming power.

The emotional sequence is painfully recognizable.

I could not prevent what happened.

I will never be powerless again.

The first statement acknowledges a terrible experience.

The second turns that experience into a demand no human being can reliably fulfill.

And once that demand becomes central to identity, almost any degree of power may begin to seem insufficient.

Padmé Must Not Die

In Revenge of the Sith, Anakin experiences visions of Padmé dying during childbirth.

The visions terrify him.

He has already lost his mother.

Now he believes he may lose his wife.

There is no ordinary way for him to tolerate the possibility.

He is not simply sad about an anticipated loss.

He becomes increasingly organized around preventing it.

The difference matters.

Fear is a normal response to the possibility of losing someone we love.

A person who learns that their partner may die does not become psychologically unhealthy merely because they desperately want that person to survive.

Seeking medical help, protecting someone from danger, and doing everything reasonably possible to reduce preventable harm are forms of care.

Anakin's problem is not that he wants Padmé to live.

It is that he gradually becomes unwilling to recognize any limit on what he may do to guarantee her survival.

The goal becomes absolute.

And an absolute goal has an unfortunate relationship with ethics.

Every competing consideration starts looking like an obstacle.

Loyalty.

Friendship.

Political responsibility.

Other people's lives.

Even Padmé's own wishes.

The more frightened he becomes, the more tempting it is to imagine that the problem can be solved through greater power.

He does not need someone to help him live with uncertainty.

He wants someone to eliminate uncertainty.

And Palpatine knows exactly what to offer.

The Man Who Offers Absolute Safety

Palpatine does not begin by demanding that Anakin become evil.

That would be an unnecessarily inefficient recruitment strategy.

Instead, he presents himself as someone who understands the young Jedi's fears.

He listens.

Recognizes Anakin's frustrations.

Encourages his resentment toward the Jedi Council.

Suggests that the Order is withholding knowledge.

And eventually introduces the possibility of powers capable of preventing death.

The promise is perfectly designed.

Anakin does not have to think of himself as betraying his values.

He can tell himself that he is doing something terrible for a beautiful reason.

He is not seeking power for its own sake.

He is seeking power to save Padmé.

The moral justification is built into the temptation.

This is what makes the manipulation psychologically convincing.

Someone who is desperate for certainty becomes vulnerable to anyone who claims to possess it.

A person frightened of abandonment may become dependent on somebody who promises never to leave.

Someone terrified of failure may follow a leader who promises a system in which failure can be eliminated.

A person unable to tolerate the possibility of death may become willing to surrender their judgment to somebody who promises mastery over mortality.

The stronger the fear, the more attractive the guarantee.

And the more attractive the guarantee, the easier it becomes to ignore the price.

Palpatine offers Anakin power over the one thing he cannot accept.

But the price of obtaining it is obedience.

Anakin wants to become powerful enough never to be helpless again.

Instead, he becomes dependent on the person who claims to know how helplessness can be abolished.

His attempt to escape fear produces a new form of captivity.

Yoda Is Right. And That Is Not Enough.

There is a scene in Revenge of the Sith that becomes considerably more uncomfortable when examined closely.

Anakin approaches Yoda for guidance.

He describes visions of someone he cares about dying.

He does not reveal that the person is his secretly married wife.

Yoda recognizes the danger of fear-driven attachment.

He advises Anakin to train himself to let go of what he fears losing.

From the perspective of Jedi doctrine, the advice makes sense.

Life changes.

Death cannot ultimately be abolished.

Attachment becomes destructive when love turns into an inability to accept change or separation.

Anakin needs to recognize that he cannot guarantee Padmé's survival.

The problem is that this perfectly reasonable philosophical principle arrives in a conversation with someone who is terrified.

Yoda offers a teaching about impermanence.

Anakin needs help understanding what to do with the fear he is experiencing right now.

These are not identical tasks.

The instruction may be wise as a long-term spiritual discipline.

It is less clear that repeating it is an adequate response to a person facing what he believes is an immediate catastrophe.

Imagine someone saying:

I'm terrified that my wife is going to die.

And receiving the answer:

You must learn not to cling to what is temporary.

The statement may contain a profound truth.

It may also leave the frightened person feeling terribly alone.

Of course, Yoda does not know the complete situation.

Anakin is withholding essential information.

The secrecy of his marriage makes an honest conversation almost impossible.

And there is no reason to assume that Yoda could have prevented Anakin's eventual choices through one better response.

Still, the encounter reveals a problem worth examining.

A correct principle can become psychologically useless when it is offered without sufficient attention to the person who is supposed to apply it.

Wisdom does not become less wise because someone is frightened.

But teaching wisdom requires more than stating it.

Can an Order Teach Compassion While Fearing Attachment?

The Jedi have an interesting institutional problem.

They value compassion.

They devote their lives to protecting others.

They teach restraint, self-discipline, and service.

Yet their rules also restrict personal attachments and create difficulties around exclusive emotional commitments.

Anakin and Padmé's marriage must remain secret.

His emotional life becomes something he cannot comfortably bring into the open within the organization to which he belongs.

This is not quite the same thing as an Order that forbids all love.

In Attack of the Clones, Anakin himself explains the distinction between prohibited attachment and the compassion expected of a Jedi.

And George Lucas has repeatedly clarified that the problem is possessive love, not love itself.

But the distinction is more difficult to maintain institutionally than it is to state philosophically.

How does a Jedi learn to love deeply without possessing?

How do they face grief?

Where can they express fear, jealousy, dependence, or shame without interpreting those feelings as evidence that they are failing the ideal?

What happens when someone has not yet developed the emotional capacities the doctrine assumes?

A spiritual rule is not the same thing as the psychological ability to live by it.

Anakin has learned that he should not be attached.

That does not mean he has learned how to recognize attachment, regulate fear, tolerate loss, or speak honestly about his emotional life.

Indeed, he may have learned to hide those experiences.

And hiding a feeling is not the same thing as transforming one's relationship with it.

The Order has an excellent vocabulary for the dangers of attachment.

It appears less successful at helping this particular student work through those dangers.

That failure does not make Palpatine innocent.

Nor does it make Anakin's choices inevitable.

But it complicates the comforting interpretation that the Jedi possessed all the correct answers and Anakin merely refused to listen.

Love Is Not the Same Thing as Possession

There is an important terminological problem here.

In contemporary psychology, attachment generally refers to patterns of emotional bonding and regulation that develop in relationships.

Secure attachment is not something psychologists normally recommend eliminating.

Reliable relationships can help people tolerate distress, explore the world, and develop greater autonomy.

In Buddhism, attachment often translates concepts involving craving, clinging, and the attempt to secure permanence in experiences that cannot provide it.

These meanings overlap in ordinary language.

But they are not interchangeable.

A person can have a secure emotional bond without treating another human being as property.

They can care deeply while recognizing the other's independence.

They can grieve a loss without believing they should have possessed the power to prevent every possible loss.

So the relevant distinction is not between love and attachment in the everyday psychological sense.

It is between love and possessive clinging.

Anakin's difficulty emerges when the continued existence of Padmé in the form he needs becomes a condition he cannot negotiate.

Her survival is no longer merely something he hopes for and works to protect.

It becomes necessary to his own sense of security and control.

And the more impossible the guarantee, the more extreme his efforts become.

Padmé is gradually transformed from a separate person he loves into the center of a problem he believes only power can solve.

The tragedy is that she still has her own mind.

Her own values.

Her own political commitments.

Her own understanding of what Anakin is becoming.

And those qualities do not disappear merely because he insists he is acting for her sake.

The Moment Love Stops Listening

The confrontation on Mustafar makes the contradiction impossible to ignore.

Anakin believes that he has acquired a path toward saving Padmé.

He imagines a future in which they can remain together.

He also imagines power over the political world around them.

But Padmé does not share his vision.

She is horrified by what he has done.

She recognizes that the person standing before her has changed in ways she cannot accept.

And when Anakin sees Obi-Wan aboard her ship, he interprets the situation through betrayal and suspicion.

He attacks her.

The woman he was supposedly willing to do anything to save becomes the target of his violence.

There is no need to turn this into a simplistic claim that love inevitably becomes aggression.

It does not.

Nor should we reduce Anakin's atrocities to a psychological symptom of fear.

He has made consequential moral choices.

But the scene reveals something crucial about the relationship between care and control.

A person may become so attached to their image of protecting someone that they stop responding to the person actually present.

Anakin wants Padmé alive.

But he no longer tolerates her independent judgment.

He wants a future with her.

But only a future organized around the choices he has made.

He wants to save her.

But when she refuses his version of salvation, he experiences her as a threat.

At this point, the language of love no longer adequately describes the behavior.

The insistence on protection has become compatible with destroying the very relationship it was supposed to preserve.

The film's tragedy does not depend on treating this as a clinically realistic portrait of any particular disorder.

It shows what happens when the imagined necessity of keeping someone overwhelms the capacity to recognize who that person is.

If protecting someone requires silencing their wishes, perhaps protection is no longer the only thing being protected.

The Cruel Irony of the Prophecy

Anakin's visions concern Padmé's death.

His actions are supposed to prevent that future.

Instead, his fall contributes to the catastrophe surrounding her final hours.

The story has the structure of a self-defeating attempt at control.

A feared outcome becomes so intolerable that the person's response creates new dangers.

The fear is not simply a prediction.

It begins organizing behavior.

And behavior changes the situation.

This resembles a familiar psychological pattern, though the fictional prophecy should not be treated as a clinical mechanism.

Someone fears abandonment.

They begin monitoring their partner constantly.

Demand reassurance.

Interpret ordinary independence as rejection.

Eventually, the relationship becomes so controlled that the partner withdraws.

The withdrawal appears to confirm the original fear.

Or someone fears professional failure.

They attempt to eliminate every possible mistake.

Control every detail.

Avoid delegating.

Work without rest.

The strategy intended to prevent failure gradually produces exhaustion and reduced flexibility.

The feared outcome becomes more likely partly because of the effort to guarantee that it cannot happen.

But Star Wars adds an especially tragic dimension.

Anakin does not merely lose his attempt to save Padmé.

He destroys much of what would have made their life together worth protecting.

Trust.

Freedom.

Moral responsibility.

The possibility that she could love him as someone who still recognized her choices.

He tries to save the future while destroying the relationship that gave the future its meaning.

And eventually he becomes Darth Vader.

A man whose entire existence is defined by the failure of an attempt to prevent loss.

Luke Has the Same Problem, but Not the Same Answer

Decades later, Luke Skywalker confronts his father.

The situation is not entirely different from Anakin's.

Luke wants to save someone important.

He believes that Darth Vader, despite his crimes, still contains something of Anakin Skywalker.

Other people are skeptical.

The Emperor intends to exploit the relationship.

Luke faces enormous emotional pressure.

And his choices may determine whether he survives.

There is a temptation to describe Luke as the son who simply loves more wisely than his father.

But that makes his struggle too easy.

Luke also experiences fear and anger.

When Vader threatens to turn Leia to the dark side, Luke loses control.

He attacks.

Overpowers his father.

Severs his mechanical hand.

And suddenly stands close to committing precisely the act the Emperor wants.

The emotional structure becomes recognizable.

Someone Luke loves is threatened.

He responds with aggression.

The desire to protect becomes a justification for destructive power.

For a moment, the son is repeating the father's pattern.

The important difference is not that Luke never experiences the temptation.

It is that he recognizes it before completing the act.

He looks at Vader.

At the severed mechanical hand.

At his own gloved hand.

The visual parallel is almost brutally simple.

He can see what he is about to become.

And he stops.

The Lightsaber on the Floor

Luke's decision to throw away his lightsaber is one of the most important actions in the saga.

It can look like surrender.

In a practical sense, it is extraordinarily dangerous.

He is standing before two powerful enemies.

The Emperor is waiting for him to kill his father and take his place.

By refusing, Luke places himself at the mercy of someone who has shown very little interest in mercy.

But the action is not simply passivity.

Luke makes a choice.

He refuses to use his fear for Leia or his anger toward Vader as a reason to become what Palpatine demands.

He does not abandon his father.

Nor does he declare that everything will be fine.

He refuses to achieve the desired outcome through an action that would destroy the values for which the outcome matters.

This is a different kind of control.

Anakin tries to control another person's fate.

Luke controls his own response.

The distinction is fundamental.

We cannot guarantee that somebody we love will survive.

We cannot guarantee that they will change.

We cannot guarantee that our compassion will be reciprocated.

But we may still be able to choose how we respond to them.

Luke does not possess the power to make Vader good.

He cannot force repentance.

He cannot erase the past.

He can refuse to become another instrument of the Emperor.

And he can continue addressing his father as someone capable of making a choice.

That is not a guarantee.

It is an invitation.

The Father Who Is Finally Allowed to Choose

When the Emperor attacks Luke with Force lightning, Vader watches.

The situation confronts him with a decision.

He can remain loyal to the master whose power has defined his life.

Or he can act to save his son.

There is no reason to believe that saving Luke will also save Vader.

In fact, the action exposes him to mortal danger.

And he acts anyway.

This is an extraordinary reversal of Anakin's original tragedy.

As a young man, he was prepared to commit atrocities because he believed they would give him the power to prevent Padmé's death.

Now he chooses an act of protection without a guarantee that he will survive.

He saves Luke.

And dies.

The distinction is not between caring and not caring.

It is between protecting someone through domination and acting for someone without requiring that the action secure our own future.

There is also a limitation to the film's redemptive structure.

Vader's final act does not undo the suffering he has caused.

His crimes remain crimes.

His return to moral agency does not make the victims disappear or the consequences of his actions harmless.

Luke's compassion also should not become a prescription that people must remain close to abusive or dangerous relatives in the hope of redeeming them.

The story takes place within a mythic structure in which a final, dramatic change is possible.

Real relationships require attention to safety, accountability, and the actual behavior of the people involved.

But within that fictional structure, Luke offers something important.

He recognizes the possibility of another person's choice without claiming ownership of it.

Vader's final decision belongs to Vader.

And that may be the most meaningful difference between saving someone and trying to possess their fate.

The Helmet Comes Off

There is another scene after the apparent victory.

Luke tries to take his dying father away from the Death Star.

He does not suddenly become indifferent to the possibility of losing him.

He wants Anakin to live.

That matters.

If Luke's achievement were simply the elimination of attachment, we might expect him to accept his father's death with perfect composure and move on.

He does nothing of the kind.

He attempts to help.

But Anakin recognizes that he is dying.

He asks Luke to remove his helmet so that he can look at his son directly.

Without the mask.

Without the machinery that has maintained his existence.

Without the terrifying image through which the galaxy has known him.

For a moment, the father and son encounter one another without the armor of the previous relationship.

There is no promise that the future will be restored.

No new power capable of reversing death.

Only a brief human exchange.

Anakin accepts the end.

Luke remains with him.

And the scene is moving precisely because love has not disappeared.

The grief is real.

The connection is real.

The limit is real.

None cancels the others.

Luke does not have to stop loving his father in order to accept that he cannot keep him alive.

He tries to save him.

Recognizes the limit.

And remains present.

This is considerably closer to a meaningful distinction between love and clinging than the idea that a wise person should never become emotionally attached to anybody.

Nonattachment Is Not the Absence of Love

Zen Buddhism provides a useful philosophical comparison here, although the Jedi are not simply Buddhist monks with lightsabers.

The saga draws on several religious and mythological traditions.

Its treatment of redemption, self-sacrifice, good and evil, and spiritual survival also has important affinities with Christianity and other traditions.

But Buddhist ideas are undeniably part of the Jedi's construction.

Impermanence.

Compassion.

Discipline.

The dangers of craving and possessive attachment.

The distinction between the immediate experience of fear and the actions we take because of it.

In Buddhism, nonattachment is not accurately described as never loving anyone.

Nor is equanimity equivalent to indifference.

Compassion involves recognizing and responding to suffering.

Nonattachment concerns, among other things, our relationship to craving, clinging, and the insistence that impermanent realities must remain permanently available to us.

Love does not become morally suspect merely because losing someone would hurt.

Grief is not evidence that a person has failed at compassion.

And acceptance does not require abandoning appropriate action to protect life.

The relevant question is whether care remains responsive to reality.

Can we take someone to a doctor without demanding that medicine guarantee immortality?

Can we love a partner without requiring that their feelings and choices remain permanently unchanged?

Can we remain present during illness without interpreting uncertainty as an intolerable personal failure?

Can we act decisively when action may help and recognize limits when action can no longer change the outcome?

These questions are more demanding than the simple instruction to let go.

They require both involvement and restraint.

The willingness to act.

And the willingness not to turn every outcome into an object of possession.

The Trouble With Teaching Wisdom as a Rule

There is still something unresolved about the Jedi.

Their philosophy contains valuable distinctions.

But their institutional practices do not always demonstrate the emotional flexibility those distinctions require.

Anakin's experience exposes the danger of treating nonattachment primarily as a prohibition.

Do not become attached.

Do not possess.

Do not fear loss.

These instructions describe an ideal.

They do not necessarily teach a frightened person how to move toward it.

In fact, the demand not to feel something can create another problem.

The person becomes ashamed of experiencing the feeling.

They hide it.

Stop seeking help.

And become increasingly dependent on anyone who offers relief without judgment.

Palpatine exploits this vulnerability.

He does not offer Anakin a better way to tolerate fear.

He offers a way to make fear unnecessary by obtaining enough power.

That is precisely the kind of promise an emotionally isolated person may find irresistible.

But the Jedi's failure is not proof that the opposite approach, unlimited emotional attachment, would have been wiser.

Their central insight remains important.

Love becomes dangerous when another person's survival, choices, or continued availability are treated as conditions we must control absolutely.

The problem is translating that insight into human relationships.

A spiritual discipline that aims to loosen possessiveness should not require denying the existence of fear, grief, or particular affection.

Otherwise, nonattachment itself becomes an object of attachment.

The Jedi can become attached to being unattached.

To appearing serene.

To obeying an ideal image of emotional mastery.

And then a frightened young man appears, desperately needing help with an experience that does not fit the ideal.

The doctrine has an answer.

But the person may still need someone to stay in the room and help him understand how to live with it.

What Luke Learns That Anakin Could Not

The contrast between father and son is not a simple victory of emotion over discipline.

Luke does not succeed by rejecting every Jedi teaching.

Nor does he succeed by following every instruction literally.

He uses what he has learned while remaining capable of responding to the particular person before him.

He recognizes the danger of anger.

Refuses the Emperor's invitation to kill.

Maintains compassion for Vader.

And accepts the possibility that his actions may not produce the outcome he desires.

This is a more flexible form of moral agency.

He is not indifferent.

He is not omnipotent.

He does not possess certainty.

He acts.

Then allows the consequences to unfold beyond his control.

The central difference between Luke and Anakin is therefore not how intensely they love.

It concerns whether love remains compatible with another person's reality.

Anakin cannot tolerate Padmé's possible death.

Then cannot tolerate her disagreement.

His love becomes inseparable from a demand that the world conform to his need for security.

Luke wants Vader to return to the light.

But his final decision does not require Vader's transformation in order to remain his decision.

He refuses to kill his father.

He refuses to become a Sith.

He accepts the risk that the Emperor will destroy him.

Vader may change.

Or may not.

Luke cannot guarantee the answer.

And the refusal to guarantee it is not a failure of love.

It is the boundary beyond which love would become coercion.

Can You Love Someone Without Owning Their Fate?

The question is not only relevant to a galaxy far, far away.

It appears in much smaller, more ordinary relationships.

A parent wants to protect a child from failure.

But protecting the child begins to mean preventing any choice that might produce disappointment.

A partner wants to preserve the relationship.

But preserving the relationship begins to require controlling the other person's movements, friendships, or decisions.

Someone caring for an ill relative becomes so frightened of loss that every expression of the patient's independent wishes feels like a threat.

A person cannot tolerate uncertainty about somebody they love.

So they monitor, demand reassurance, prepare for catastrophe, and attempt to eliminate every possible source of danger.

These situations are not identical, and actual protection may be necessary, especially where children or vulnerable people depend on us.

But they illustrate a recurring tension.

Care is concerned with another person's well-being.

Control is concerned with making outcomes conform to our requirements.

Sometimes the two overlap.

We may need to intervene to prevent immediate harm.

But they can also diverge.

A person may be highly controlling while believing sincerely that they are acting from love.

The question then becomes uncomfortable.

Am I responding to what this person actually needs?

Or attempting to eliminate the anxiety I experience when I imagine losing them?

Am I protecting their freedom to live?

Or protecting myself from the possibility that their life will not unfold as I wish?

And if the two demands conflict, which one am I prepared to respect?

The answers will not always be simple.

Love involves responsibility, dependence, and sometimes difficult decisions.

Nonattachment is not a universal instruction to stand aside.

But neither is love a license to make the other person's existence into an extension of our own need for certainty.

The Last Lesson of the Skywalkers

There is something almost cruel about the symmetry of the two stories.

Anakin turns to the dark side in the hope of preventing a death.

He acquires power.

Loses Padmé.

And spends years as the servant of the person who promised him control over mortality.

Luke refuses to kill his father.

He rejects the offer of power.

Vader chooses to save him.

And dies.

Neither story offers an escape from loss.

The difference is what happens to love when loss becomes possible.

Anakin treats the possibility as an emergency that justifies overriding almost everything else.

Luke eventually allows love to guide an action without allowing the desired result to justify every possible action.

This is not a promise that compassion will always succeed.

It does not guarantee redemption.

It does not mean that someone we love will change because we have finally found the correct emotional attitude.

And it certainly does not make bereavement painless.

It means that love can remain meaningful without giving us authority over the final outcome.

Sometimes we can save someone.

Sometimes we cannot.

Sometimes we can help, protect, accompany, or reduce suffering.

Sometimes we discover that our power has reached its limit.

The difficult part is learning to distinguish these situations without turning our fear into a demand for unlimited control.

And perhaps the most mature form of care is not the one that feels least afraid.

It is the one that can recognize fear without allowing fear to decide what love must become.

Luke still wants his father to live.

He still attempts to carry him to safety.

And when the end arrives, he does not pretend that the loss is unimportant.

He remains there.

With someone he loves.

In a moment neither of them can control.

There is no spectacular victory over death.

No secret technique that finally makes human attachment safe from loss.

Only the recognition that the relationship mattered, the choices made within it mattered, and neither requires the power to make it last forever.

To love someone is to care what happens to them.

To possess someone is to insist that what happens to them must remain under our control.

Anakin spends his life confusing the two.

Luke finally discovers that the first is possible without the second.

And perhaps that is what makes his choice a victory.

Not that he prevents death.

But that, for one decisive moment, he refuses to let the fear of death determine what he is willing to destroy.

Sources

Keep reading

Explore the writing archive →

Stay in touch

More essays and updates on ABVX Substack.

Read and subscribe on Substack →