An illustrated face and an empty chair in a dark interior.

Cover image supplied from the owner-authorized Psychology Notebook reserve.

Attention, the infraordinary, and the difficulty of seeing the world without making it about ourselves.

There is a remarkably efficient way to ruin an otherwise pleasant afternoon in Paris.

Sit down at a café.

Order something.

Look around.

And realize that absolutely nothing interesting is happening.

No dramatic argument. No attractive strangers falling in love. No philosophical revelation. No charming little incident that will make an excellent story when you get home.

Just people walking.

Cars moving.

A pigeon behaving like a pigeon.

A bus arriving, collecting passengers, and leaving.

Then another bus.

The city has apparently forgotten its obligation to entertain you.

Most of us would reach for our phones.

Georges Perec reached for his notebook.

And in October 1974, he spent three days attempting something that sounds both magnificently pointless and unexpectedly difficult.

He tried to describe a Parisian square until there was nothing left to describe.

Not its monuments.

Not its history.

Not the architectural masterpieces that already had their place in guidebooks.

The other things.

The things nobody thought worth mentioning.

What happens when, apparently, nothing happens.

And the more closely he looked, the more obvious it became that nothing was a rather crowded place.

The Most Boring Assignment in Paris

On Friday, October 18, 1974, Perec begins his observations at Place Saint-Sulpice in Paris's sixth arrondissement.

He records the date.

The time.

The location.

The weather.

Then begins listing what he can see.

Signs.

Letters.

Numbers.

Buildings.

Fragments of advertising.

Vehicles.

Trees.

Pigeons.

People.

A dog.

A baguette.

Some lettuce emerging from a shopping bag.

Even the sky receives a rough measurement: approximately one-sixth of his visual field.

An impressive level of attention for something most people would describe as a perfectly ordinary morning.

He returns to the square repeatedly over three consecutive days, observing it from different positions, often from café windows or terraces.

The result is An Attempt at Exhausting a Place in Paris, first published in 1975.

It is a short, strange book.

There is almost no conventional plot.

No central character whose difficulties demand resolution.

No murder.

No romance.

No extraordinary transformation.

A wedding and a funeral occur around the church, but Perec does not reorganize the entire text into a grand meditation on the human condition.

He continues noticing other things.

Buses.

Passersby.

The weather.

The movement of pigeons.

The passing of time.

There is something almost confrontational about this refusal to turn ordinary life into a proper literary event.

We are accustomed to literature selecting what matters.

Perec seems determined to investigate everything that does not.

The Strange Category of the Infraordinary

Perec was interested in what he called the infraordinary.

Not the extraordinary.

Not even simply the ordinary.

But the almost invisible layer of everyday existence that disappears beneath our expectations of what deserves attention.

We notice a traffic accident.

We rarely notice the previous thousand cars that reached their destinations without difficulty.

We notice a dramatic encounter.

We rarely notice the hundreds of small negotiations through which strangers share a pavement.

We remember the exceptional meal.

We forget most of the meals that kept us alive.

Ordinary life is composed overwhelmingly of things we do not consider events.

And because they are not events, we often behave as though they have not happened.

This is an interesting psychological habit.

We tend to organize experience around significance.

Something deserves our attention because it is unusual, threatening, rewarding, relevant to our goals, or connected to something we already care about.

The rest becomes background.

Perec is interested in that background.

Not because he has discovered a hidden mystical truth behind the movement of a bus.

But because the category of the insignificant is itself worth examining.

Why do we assume that some experiences deserve description while others do not?

Who decided that a bus passing through a square was not an event?

And what happens to our understanding of life when we exclude nearly everything that life consists of?

The question is almost embarrassingly simple.

Which may be why we so rarely ask it.

The Brain Is an Extremely Selective Editor

Psychology provides a useful explanation for our difficulty noticing ordinary things.

Attention is selective.

We cannot consciously process every aspect of our environment with equal depth.

Our perceptual systems continuously prioritize some information over other information, depending on current tasks, expectations, sensory features, and previous experience.

This is usually helpful.

If you are trying to cross a busy street, it is a good idea to pay more attention to approaching vehicles than to the aesthetic properties of every paving stone.

But selective attention has a surprising consequence.

Things can be directly in front of us without becoming part of our conscious awareness.

The classic research on inattentional blindness, associated with Daniel Simons and Christopher Chabris, illustrates this problem.

When people concentrate on a demanding visual task, they may fail to notice an unexpected event that is plainly visible in the scene.

The event is present.

The eyes may even be directed toward the relevant area.

But attention has been organized elsewhere.

This does not mean we are blind to most of reality in a literal sense.

It means conscious perception is more selective than our subjective experience suggests.

We feel as though we are seeing the world.

Often, we are seeing the portion that our current task has made relevant.

Now consider what happens when the task changes.

Instead of looking for something important, Perec decides to attend to things normally classified as unimportant.

Suddenly, buses become visible as buses.

Not simply transportation.

Their numbers, routes, frequency, and recurrence become material.

Pigeons cease being an anonymous visual texture.

Their movements become worth describing.

The ordinary world has not become more detailed.

The observer has changed what counts as detail.

The Trouble With Buses

At first, buses are among the most attractive objects for Perec's experiment.

They have numbers.

Recognizable routes.

Repeated appearances.

They are easy to identify.

They provide a reassuring structure for observation.

A bus passes.

It has a number.

Another appears.

The number is recorded.

An ordinary square becomes a place where time can be divided into recognizable arrivals and departures.

The buses effectively provide the experiment with a rhythm.

And then something interesting happens.

Perec becomes bored with them.

On the second day, he acknowledges that he has lost interest in the buses.

This is one of the most psychologically revealing moments in the book.

The observer set out to escape conventional hierarchies of importance.

But his own attention begins creating new ones.

The buses were interesting.

Now they are repetitive.

The same kind of event that previously deserved recording begins to disappear into the background.

Attention has habituated.

The experiment has run into the ordinary limitations of being human.

We can decide to notice something.

We cannot guarantee that it will remain equally interesting.

And perhaps this is the first important complication in any philosophy of attention.

The instruction to notice everything sounds admirable.

It is also impossible.

Even the person attempting to observe without prejudice develops preferences, expectations, and fatigue.

Perec does not overcome these limitations.

He records some of them.

The observer becomes part of the observation.

What Counts as Something Happening?

There is an almost philosophical comedy in the title An Attempt at Exhausting a Place in Paris.

To exhaust something suggests completing the inventory.

Everything has been noticed.

Everything has been described.

Nothing remains.

An ambitious undertaking for a writer sitting in a café.

Because a square is not a fixed collection of objects waiting patiently to be counted.

It is a continuing process.

People arrive and leave.

Light changes.

Weather alters the appearance of surfaces.

Traffic fluctuates.

The same objects appear different at different times.

Even something apparently stable, like a building, participates in changing relationships with everything around it.

Perec notices some of these variations.

Saturday is not quite Friday.

Sunday has different rhythms.

Some places are closed.

There are changes in traffic and the movement of pedestrians.

Rain produces umbrellas.

The same square remains recognizable while never quite becoming the same scene twice.

And then there is the problem of simultaneous events.

While Perec records one action, countless others continue.

A bus arrives while someone crosses the street.

A bird takes flight while a car turns.

A conversation occurs outside his hearing.

Something happens behind him.

The notebook moves in a line.

Reality does not.

Language can record events sequentially.

The world produces them simultaneously.

Exhausting the square is therefore impossible, not merely because the writer lacks sufficient patience.

The object of observation keeps changing.

And even if it stopped, the observer could never attend to every aspect of it at once.

The attempt is doomed.

Which is precisely what makes it interesting.

A Zen Reading Without the Enlightenment Story

There is an obvious temptation to turn Perec's experiment into a lesson in mindfulness.

A writer sits quietly.

Observes pigeons.

Notices the weather.

Pays attention to the present.

Clearly, he has discovered the secret of Zen.

Unfortunately, that would be rather too easy.

Perec's project belongs to a particular literary and intellectual context, including his interest in formal constraints, everyday life, observation, and the work of Oulipo.

There are also scholarly discussions of Japanese aesthetic influences on his writing.

But we should not turn this specific book into an undocumented account of Buddhist practice.

The comparison with Zen is useful as a philosophical experiment, not as a claim about Perec's spiritual intentions.

Zen Buddhist traditions involve much more than paying attention to mundane objects.

They include disciplined practice, ethical commitments, and the cultivation of wisdom and compassion.

Still, one aspect of the tradition is relevant to Perec's experiment.

Our habitual conceptual distinctions can become so automatic that they determine what we are able to experience.

Important.

Unimportant.

Interesting.

Boring.

Beautiful.

Ugly.

Useful.

Meaningless.

We do not merely observe the world and then attach these labels.

The labels also influence what we notice in the first place.

A tourist arriving at Place Saint-Sulpice might immediately identify the church as the important object.

The café is useful because it provides refreshment.

The buses are irrelevant unless one needs transportation.

The pigeons are background decoration, or perhaps a minor public nuisance.

The square has already been divided into categories of significance.

Perec suspends some of those expectations.

What if the bus deserves attention?

What if the pigeon is not merely background?

What if the ordinary movement of people is sufficient material for observation without requiring an event to justify it?

This resonates with a Zen-inspired effort to loosen attachment to rigid conceptual distinctions.

But the connection should not be exaggerated.

Perec is still categorizing, selecting, and writing.

His experiment is not an escape from language.

It is an experiment conducted through language.

Which creates another, more interesting question.

Can writing help us notice the world without immediately taking possession of it through explanation?

The Pigeon Does Not Owe You a Metaphor

Imagine watching a group of pigeons suddenly take flight.

An ordinary event.

The birds rise, circle, and settle again.

You could simply observe them.

But the human mind is extraordinarily talented at making things mean something.

The flight becomes an image of freedom.

Or anxiety.

Or the fragility of existence.

Or the impossibility of remaining in one place.

Perhaps the pigeons represent modern society.

Perhaps the entire square is a metaphor for the human condition.

Within a few moments, the birds have acquired several philosophical responsibilities they did not request.

This is one of our characteristic ways of encountering the world.

We convert what we see into stories.

Often stories about ourselves.

A dog sitting alone becomes a symbol of loneliness.

A couple arguing becomes evidence that relationships are doomed.

An old person walking slowly becomes a reminder of mortality.

A child laughing becomes proof that life was better when we were young.

These interpretations can be moving and sometimes useful.

They are also additions.

The dog may simply be waiting for its owner.

The couple may be discussing directions.

The elderly person may be enjoying a perfectly pleasant walk.

And the pigeons are probably occupied with pigeon matters.

Perec's restrained descriptions offer the possibility of allowing an ordinary event to remain ordinary.

Not everything needs to become an allegory.

Not everything must reinforce our philosophy.

Not everything we encounter exists to teach us something.

There is a strange generosity in this kind of attention.

It allows the world to appear without immediately requiring it to become part of our personal narrative.

But Is Pure Observation Possible?

Here we encounter the central contradiction.

Perec attempts to describe what is visible.

But he must decide what to record.

He notices a number on a bus.

A fragment of lettering.

A particular movement.

A change in the weather.

Why these details?

Why not the shape of every paving stone?

The precise distance between two pedestrians?

The number of leaves on a tree?

The emotional state of a person passing by?

Some things are inaccessible.

Others are simply overlooked.

And some become interesting because they belong to categories the observer has already begun to use.

Even the decision to record insignificant things creates a new rule of significance.

The insignificant now matters precisely because it is insignificant.

This makes the project more complicated than a straightforward celebration of unfiltered perception.

There is no completely neutral notebook.

The observer brings habits.

Language.

Expectations.

Memory.

Fatigue.

A particular position in space.

The book itself makes some of these conditions visible through its timestamps, changes of location, remarks about the weather, and occasional acknowledgments of what the writer cannot know.

At one point, Perec reflects on whether the pigeons appearing on successive days might be the same birds.

It is a wonderfully modest uncertainty.

The birds are visible.

Their identities are not.

The observation cannot supply everything the observer might want to know.

And rather than inventing a confident explanation, Perec leaves the uncertainty in place.

This is perhaps more interesting than the fantasy of pure perception.

Not a person who sees reality without interpretation.

But a person who can sometimes recognize where observation ends and interpretation begins.

A small distinction.

And an extremely useful one.

Why Boredom Is Such an Uncomfortable Experience

There is another psychological aspect of the book worth exploring.

Boredom.

Modern life is extraordinarily well equipped to prevent it.

We carry devices capable of supplying entertainment, conversation, information, conflict, shopping, and an effectively unlimited quantity of other people's lives.

Almost any empty interval can be filled.

Waiting for a train?

There is something to read.

Sitting in a café?

Someone has posted something outrageous.

Standing in a queue?

An entire world of distractions is available.

We rarely have to confront a moment in which nothing seems sufficiently interesting.

Perec deliberately enters that situation.

The square provides no guarantee of entertainment.

He cannot force an extraordinary event to occur.

He can only continue observing.

Boredom may therefore become part of the experiment.

Not necessarily something to eliminate.

Something to recognize.

And boredom is psychologically interesting because it involves our relationship with attention and meaning.

We become bored not simply because the environment contains nothing, but because we are unable or unwilling to engage satisfactorily with what is available.

Sometimes the environment really is unstimulating.

Sometimes exhaustion or depression affects our capacity for interest.

And sometimes we have become so accustomed to pursuing particular forms of stimulation that quieter experiences seem almost invisible.

Perec's experiment does not prove that careful observation cures boredom.

He himself becomes tired of certain repetitions.

But it suggests that boredom is not always a reliable measure of how much is happening.

A street can be full of activity.

And the observer can still be bored.

The problem may be less the absence of events than the expectation that an event must justify our attention.

A City Without a Protagonist

One of the most radical features of Perec's experiment is the absence of a central hero.

There is no person around whom the square organizes itself.

A bus driver has a route.

A pedestrian has somewhere to go.

Someone enters a café.

Someone leaves.

A group of pigeons moves through the air.

Each belongs to a different process.

None is necessarily the protagonist of the others.

Yet our minds often convert shared spaces into personal narratives.

The city becomes the setting for my journey.

The café is where I am waiting.

The crowd is what prevents me from reaching my destination.

The weather is something that improves or ruins my afternoon.

Everyone else becomes part of the environment through which the central character, myself, is moving.

This is usually harmless.

We necessarily experience the world from a particular position.

But it can narrow our understanding of other people's lives.

The person walking slowly in front of me is not simply an obstacle.

The waiter who takes too long is not merely a delay.

The bus that arrives at an inconvenient moment is not evidence of the universe's personal hostility.

Other people are pursuing lives that do not exist primarily in relation to my plans.

Perec's writing does not eliminate his own point of view.

Everything is still observed from somewhere.

But the resulting text reduces the demand for a central personal plot.

People can pass through without being assigned elaborate psychological identities.

An encounter can remain brief.

A gesture can remain unexplained.

An event can happen without transforming the narrator.

This is a peculiar kind of literary modesty.

The writer is present.

But the world is not required to revolve around him.

The Difference Between Looking and Collecting

There is also a danger in the experiment.

Attention can become another form of possession.

Perec wants to record the square.

To create an inventory.

To leave a trace of things that would otherwise disappear.

The ambition is beautiful.

It is also impossible to complete.

No amount of writing can preserve every moment of a place.

The writer must choose.

The record must end.

The square continues.

Here the difference between Perec's literary project and a Zen-inspired philosophy of attention becomes particularly useful.

A literary inventory transforms perception into an artifact.

The observed event becomes a sentence.

The sentence becomes part of a book.

A fleeting moment acquires a certain permanence.

But Zen-inspired nonattachment would raise a further question.

Can we allow an experience to occur without needing to preserve it?

Without photographing it?

Cataloguing it?

Explaining it?

Turning it into evidence of our sensitivity?

Even the urge to notice everything can become an ambition.

Another project of mastery.

I will observe more than other people.

I will capture what they fail to see.

I will exhaust the ordinary world through the intensity of my attention.

Perec's title contains its own correction to this fantasy.

It is an attempt.

Not an achievement.

The world remains inexhaustible.

The observer leaves.

The square does not become his property.

And perhaps the impossibility of completion is one of the work's most important discoveries.

Attention can deepen our relationship with experience.

It cannot give us ownership of experience.

A Three-Minute Experiment

There is a simple way to understand what Perec is doing.

Choose an ordinary place.

A café.

A train platform.

A park bench.

A view from your window.

Somewhere nothing particularly interesting is expected to happen.

For three minutes, observe what is there.

Not what the place reminds you of.

Not what it means for your life.

Not whether the people look happy, successful, lonely, or suspicious.

Begin with concrete details.

A person carrying a red bag.

A bus stopping.

Someone adjusting their coat.

A sound from the street.

A change in light.

A bird landing and taking off.

You can write these observations down if you like.

Then look at what you recorded.

How much did you actually see?

What did you ignore?

Did you begin looking for particular categories of things?

Did you notice vehicles more easily than people?

Movements more readily than stillness?

Did an ordinary event suddenly seem worth describing?

And when did you become bored?

Now comes the more difficult part.

Notice the moments when observation became interpretation.

A person was walking quickly.

You decided they were anxious.

Two people were talking quietly.

You imagined they were having an argument.

Someone sat alone.

You concluded they were lonely.

Perhaps you were right.

Perhaps not.

The experiment is not about eliminating interpretation.

That would be impossible.

It is about recognizing the difference between what appeared and the story you began constructing around it.

Then put the notebook away.

Look for another minute without trying to record anything.

No inventory.

No performance.

Nothing to preserve.

The place continues.

You do not have to accomplish anything with it.

This is not a formal Zen exercise, and it will not produce enlightenment between ordering coffee and paying the bill.

But it may reveal something about the ordinary way we distribute attention.

And how quickly we turn experience into explanation.

The Quiet Sadness of the Ordinary

There is something unexpectedly moving about Perec's little book.

Not because it contains a tragic story.

But because its subject is made of moments that disappear almost as soon as they occur.

A bus passes.

A person crosses the square.

Rain begins.

The light changes.

A bird takes flight.

Nobody marks these events as historically important.

Most will never be remembered.

Yet they happened.

And together they formed a particular afternoon in a particular city, among people whose lives briefly intersected.

The next day, the square looks familiar.

But it is not the same.

Some people have returned.

Others have not.

Certain movements repeat.

Others occur only once.

The city continues without preserving a complete account of itself.

Perec's notebook offers a small resistance to this disappearance.

Not a victory.

He cannot save everything.

But he can record a little of what would otherwise pass unnoticed.

There is a temptation to explain this impulse through the losses in Perec's biography, including the deaths of his parents during the Second World War.

His writing certainly invites serious discussions of memory, absence, and disappearance.

But reducing every pigeon or bus to a disguised symbol of childhood trauma would defeat much of what makes this particular experiment interesting.

Sometimes the most respectful thing we can do for a literary work is allow its ordinary details to remain ordinary.

And perhaps that is also a form of respect for the world.

Not every moment needs a hidden wound to justify its existence.

A bus can matter because a bus passed.

Nothing Happened, Except a Life

The most interesting thing about An Attempt at Exhausting a Place in Paris is that it does not finally prove that everything is meaningful.

That would be too convenient.

It does not reveal that every ordinary gesture contains a profound secret.

It does not convert pigeons into spiritual teachers or public transportation into an elaborate metaphor for existence.

Instead, it questions the demand that things must become meaningful in a particular way before we consider them worthy of attention.

We are accustomed to evaluating experience through what it provides.

Was it interesting?

Was it productive?

Did we learn something?

Did it make us happy?

Can we tell a story about it?

Was it worth our time?

These questions are not inherently wrong.

But they can become so dominant that experiences without immediate significance begin to disappear from our lives.

We wait for the event.

The achievement.

The relationship.

The revelation.

The thing that will finally make the day worth remembering.

Meanwhile, the day happens.

People walk.

Clouds move.

Buses arrive.

The light changes.

And a remarkable quantity of living takes place without asking permission to become a story.

The psychological challenge is recognizing how selectively we attend to this world.

The Zen-inspired challenge is learning to encounter experience without immediately demanding that it justify itself through our expectations, preferences, or personal narrative.

And the literary challenge, the one Perec actually undertakes, is to see whether language can bring some of that neglected world into view.

None of these projects can be completed perfectly.

Observation remains selective.

Language remains incomplete.

The mind continues interpreting.

And the world continues changing faster than we can describe it.

But perhaps complete success was never necessary.

There is something valuable in the attempt itself.

To look again.

To notice what was there all along.

To become curious about something that has no particular reason to interest us.

And, occasionally, to allow what we see to remain outside the story of ourselves.

Perec spent three days watching a Parisian square.

He could not exhaust it.

Of course he couldn't.

It was a place full of ordinary life.

And ordinary life has the inconvenient habit of continuing.

Perhaps the problem is not that nothing happens when we are paying attention.

Perhaps it is that we have become so accustomed to deciding what matters that we no longer notice how much of life happens without needing to matter to us.

Sources

Keep reading

Explore the writing archive →

Stay in touch

More essays and updates on ABVX Substack.

Read and subscribe on Substack →